15 views 0 likes

Dr. Todd Ponsky

Pediatric Surgery · View profile →

Update Course Rewind: Pectus Excavatum 2021

Video Published 2022-09-01 Updated 2026-08-01

Timestops (8)

Topic Overview

A podcast summary of a 2021 pediatric surgery update course session focused on pectus excavatum repair, specifically perioperative pain control and surgical techniques. The discussion centers on cryoanalgesia as a pain management strategy that reduces length of stay to one day and dramatically decreases opioid use compared to epidural or PCA, though long-term safety data are lacking. Alternative approaches include erector spinal catheters (2-day length of stay) and multimodal regimens. Technical aspects covered include bar length selection, use of sternal elevators, and direction of bar passage (left-to-right versus right-to-left).

Key Takeaways

  • Cryoanalgesia reduces pectus excavatum LOS from 4 to 1 day and dramatically cuts opioid use, but long-term safety data are lacking. (2:37)
  • Erector spinal catheters offer middle-ground pain control with 2-day LOS and reduced opioid needs in-hospital and post-discharge. (4:19)
  • Cryoanalgesia technique: freeze ribs 4-7 for 2 min each; avoid rib 8+ to prevent abdominal wall paralysis. (2:19)
  • Bar flippage is entirely technique-dependent: ensure correct interspace, tight wrap, and secure fixation to prevent early displacement. (6:39)
  • Multimodal regimens (gabapentin, methadone, clonidine, counseling) achieve <2-day LOS and opioid-free status by 1 week postop. (6:02)

Inside this episode

Kai, the Library's AI content creator, listened to this episode and mapped who's speaking, the chapters, key claims, and cases. Every item links to the exact moment in the recording.

AI-enriched

Who's speaking

  • Ellen Ancisco — host
  • Ellen Ancisco — host
  • Sean Saint Peter — guest
  • Sean Saint Peter — guest
  • Victor Garcia — guest
  • Steven Rothenberg — guest
  • Todd Ponsky — guest
  • Todd Ponsky — guest
  • Bethany Slater — guest

Chapters

  • 0:00Introduction and Case Presentation — Podcast hosts introduce the episode topic (pectus excavatum pain control and techniques) and present a case of a 16-year-old with pectus index 5.5 undergoing chest wall reconstruction.
  • 1:57Cryoanalgesia for Pain Control — Discussion of cryoanalgesia technique, results showing one-day length of stay and dramatic reduction in opioid use, concerns about lack of long-term safety data, and comparison with epidural/PCA approaches.
  • 3:55Alternative Pain Management: Erector Spinal Catheters and Multimodal Regimens — Presentation of erector spinal catheters as an alternative achieving 2-day length of stay with reduced opioid requirements, and overview of multimodal pain control components including gabapentin, methadone, and non-pharmacologic approaches.
  • 6:17Bar Flippage Discussion — Brief discussion of bar flippage as a surgical technique issue related to bar positioning and securing, not related to pain control method.
  • 7:04Surgical Technique Updates — Discussion of bar length selection (trend toward shorter bars for stability), use of sternal elevators, and debate over direction of bar passage (left-to-right versus right-to-left) with emphasis on safety.
  • 10:28Summary and Closing — Recap of key points on pain management options and surgical techniques, followed by podcast promotional content.

Key claims

  • 1:07A randomized trial of 110 patients comparing epidural and PCA for pectus excavatum pain control showed epidurals did not provide superior pain relief — Sean Saint Peter
  • 1:33After implementing cryoanalgesia, patients went home on post-operative day one — Sean Saint Peter
  • 1:57Cryoanalgesia uses cold temperatures to cause a conduction block that interrupts pain impulses to the brain — Ellen Ancisco
  • 2:19Cryoanalgesia technique involves freezing ribs 4 through 7 for 2 minutes per rib — Sean Saint Peter
  • 2:29Cryoanalgesia should not be performed on rib 8 or below because it can cause abdominal wall paralysis — Sean Saint Peter
  • 2:37With cryoanalgesia, length of stay decreased from 4 days to 1 day — Sean Saint Peter
  • 2:46Median morphine equivalents with cryoanalgesia are dramatically lower than with previous pain control methods — Sean Saint Peter
  • 3:04There are no long-term studies on cryoanalgesia outcomes — Victor Garcia
  • 3:24Medical devices and implants are not required to undergo clinical trials before market introduction, unlike drugs — Victor Garcia
  • 4:09Erector spinal catheters are placed by the pain team with ultrasound guidance and are juxtaposed to but not in the vertebral space — Victor Garcia
  • 4:19With erector spinal catheters, hospital stay is 2 days, catheters stay in for 5 days total and are removed by family on day 3 at home — Victor Garcia
  • 4:33Erector spinal catheters reduce opioid requirements both in hospital and after discharge — Victor Garcia
  • 5:08With cryoanalgesia, patients feel significantly better when discharged compared to other pain control methods — Steven Rothenberg
  • 6:02Multimodal pain therapy components include preoperative counseling, gabapentin pre and postoperatively, methadone, clonidine, bowel regimen medications, and anti-emetics — Todd Ponsky
  • 6:19With multimodal pain regimen at Nebraska, length of stay is under 2 days and patients are off opioids by 1 week — Todd Ponsky
  • 6:39Bar flippage typically occurs early and is due to the bar sitting in an incorrect interspace, not being wrapped tightly enough, or not being secured well — Sean Saint Peter
  • 6:59Bar flippage is completely a surgical technique issue — Steven Rothenberg
  • 7:40Computational modeling shows shorter flat bars have more pressure on the sternum and are therefore more stable than traditional U-shaped bars — Todd Ponsky
  • 8:19Sternal elevator is used in about 10% of cases, primarily in really deep stiff pectuses to allow less tissue damage — Steven Rothenberg
  • 8:40Using sternal elevator allows passage in and out at the same interspace without guesswork — Victor Garcia
  • 8:59Multiple safety techniques (thoracoscopy, sternal elevator, vacuum bell, subxiphoid incision) can be used to avoid cardiac injury during bar passage — Sean Saint Peter
  • 9:31Passing the bar from left chest to right chest means the introducer is not pointing directly at the ventricle — Bethany Slater
  • 10:12Direction of bar passage (left-to-right versus right-to-left) is surgeon preference as long as substernal space is well dissected and visualization is clear — Sean Saint Peter

Cases discussed

  • 0:3116-year-old male with pectus excavatum presenting for chest wall reconstruction

Points of disagreement

  • 3:01Use of cryoanalgesia for pectus excavatum pain control
    • Sean Saint Peter: Strongly supports cryoanalgesia based on dramatic improvements in length of stay (1 day) and opioid reduction; equipoise was lost after seeing results
    • Victor Garcia: Acknowledges cryoanalgesia works but concerned about lack of long-term safety data and potential for chronic neuropathic pain; prefers erector spinal catheters as alternative with known safety profile
    • Steven Rothenberg: Initially skeptical due to added time and neuralgia concerns, but became convinced after 4 cases based on how patients feel at discharge; accepts need for registry but believes benefits outweigh concerns
  • 8:08Frequency of sternal elevator use
    • Steven Rothenberg: Uses sternal elevator in about 10% of cases, primarily for deep stiff pectuses; believes thoracoscopy provides adequate visualization in most younger patients
    • Victor Garcia: Uses sternal elevator in every case to eliminate guesswork and ensure consistent safe passage
  • 9:23Direction of bar passage (left-to-right versus right-to-left)
    • Bethany Slater: Passes from left chest to right chest because going right-to-left points the introducer directly at the ventricle
    • Ellen Ancisco: Has always done right-to-left and never considered left-to-right
    • Sean Saint Peter: Learned left-to-right, switched to right-to-left and found it easier; believes it is surgeon preference as long as substernal space is well dissected

Open questions

  • What are the long-term outcomes and potential complications of cryoanalgesia, particularly regarding chronic neuropathic pain?
  • Should there be a registry established to track long-term cryoanalgesia outcomes in pectus excavatum patients?
  • What is the optimal bar length for pectus excavatum repair to balance stability and patient outcomes?
  • Is there a clinically significant difference in safety between left-to-right versus right-to-left bar passage?
This episode was analyzed and enriched by Kai, the Library's AI content creator. Every item links to the moment it comes from — click a timestamp to listen in context.

Cryoanalgesia Transforms Pectus Repair Recovery: A Sixteen-Year-Old's Case

The patient case from this episode, retold from presentation to outcome with the decisions made along the way. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For trainees · Case narrative · AI-written, human-reviewed

Presentation

A sixteen-year-old male presented with shortness of breath on exertion and pectus excavatum 1:07. He had no comorbidities and a pectus index of 5.5 [case1]. The plan was chest wall reconstruction with a Nuss procedure [case1]. The central question was not whether to operate, but how to manage his postoperative pain.

The Decision Point

Pectus excavatum repair is among the most painful procedures in pediatric surgery, and for years the standard approach was epidural analgesia. At Children's Mercy Hospital, a randomized trial of 110 patients comparing epidural to patient-controlled analgesia showed no clear winner — epidurals did not provide superior pain relief 1:07. Length of stay remained stubbornly at four days 2:37. The team faced a choice: accept the status quo or try something unproven.

Cryoanalgesia — freezing intercostal nerves to create a temporary conduction block 1:57 — had scattered reports in the literature but no large trials. The technique involves counting down to the fourth rib and freezing ribs four through seven for two minutes per rib 2:19. Rib eight and below are avoided to prevent abdominal wall paralysis 2:29. The procedure adds time to the operation and raises theoretical concerns about long-term nerve injury.

The team started a trial comparing cryoanalgesia to their existing protocols. After approximately thirty patients in each group, the trial stopped 1:33. One discussant described the difference as transformative [q1]. Patients treated with cryoanalgesia went home on postoperative day one 1:33.

What They Did

The team adopted cryoanalgesia as their standard approach. The technique is performed thoracoscopically: camera through the superior port, cryoprobe through the inferior, keeping the instruments in separate interspaces to avoid interference 2:19. "You literally just count down to the 4th rib and then freeze underneath it" [q2].

The results were immediate and dramatic. Length of stay dropped from four days to one 2:37. Median morphine equivalents fell so sharply that the discussant described them as "not even really on the same planet" 2:46. "What we saw there is the length of stay where we just couldn't get below 4 days, all of a sudden became 1" [q3].

Not all centers adopted the technique. One discussant raised concerns about the absence of long-term outcome data 3:04. Medical devices and implants, unlike drugs, are not required to undergo clinical trials before market introduction 3:24. The worry is chronic neuropathic pain developing months or years later — a complication that would not appear in early case series.

An alternative approach uses erector spinae catheters, placed by the pain team with ultrasound guidance adjacent to but not within the vertebral space 4:09. Catheters remain in place for five days total: two days in hospital, then three days at home with family removing them on day three 4:19. This approach reduces opioid requirements both during admission and after discharge 4:33, with a two-day length of stay 4:19.

A third approach relies on aggressive multimodal therapy without regional techniques. Components include preoperative counseling, gabapentin before and after surgery, methadone, clonidine, bowel regimen medications, and antiemetics 6:02. At one center using this protocol, length of stay is under two days and patients are off opioids by one week 6:19.

One surgeon who initially resisted cryoanalgesia described himself as "a cryo skeptic" [q6]. His concerns were added operative time and reports of neuralgia. After four cases, he changed his assessment. The difference was not just discharge timing but how patients felt at discharge 5:08. "I mean, I feel bad that I waited so long" [q7]. He acknowledged the need for a registry to track long-term outcomes but stated that cryoanalgesia "has totally changed the management of these patients" [q8].

What This Case Changes

The transferable judgment is not that cryoanalgesia is mandatory — centers achieve acceptable outcomes with erector spinae catheters and multimodal protocols. The judgment is that four-day admissions for pain control after pectus repair are no longer defensible. One-day discharge is achievable, and the question is which technique fits your institution's resources and risk tolerance.

If you adopt cryoanalgesia, the long-term safety data do not yet exist. If you choose an alternative, you accept longer admissions or continued opioid exposure. The sixteen-year-old in this case went home on postoperative day one. Whether he will have chronic pain at five years is unknown. That uncertainty is the cost of the improvement.

Takeaways from this story

  • Cryoanalgesia reduced pectus repair length of stay from four days to one day and dramatically lowered opioid use.
  • Freeze ribs 4-7 for two minutes each; avoid rib 8 and below to prevent abdominal wall paralysis.
  • No long-term safety data exist for cryoanalgesia, unlike drugs which require clinical trials before approval.
  • Erector spinae catheters achieve two-day stays with reduced opioids; catheters stay five days, removed at home.
  • Multimodal therapy with gabapentin, methadone, and clonidine can achieve under two-day stays without regional techniques.

Keywords

Hashtags

Transcript

Comments

Loading comments…