Alexander J. Towbin · Measuring Radiology's Impact: Core Concepts for Tracking Patient-Oriented Outcomes & High-Value Care
Video10 min·Published Sep 2026

Measuring Radiology's Impact: Core Concepts for Tracking Patient-Oriented Outcomes & High-Value Care

With Dr. Thiago Braga & Dr. Elliot Siegel · hosted by Dr. Alex McKinney

Chapter 4 of 5

Efficacy hierarchy

Medical Imaging Life Cycle and Historical Context

Cued at 7:58 · press play
Try
Intelligent Search· scoped to appendicitis · not medical adviceSearch the whole library →
Only a few other public items share this expert — go deeper there →
What the experts said17 expert statements · 2 host summaries
Imaging usage has doubled nationally over the past 7 to 10 years.
EpidemiologicalAlex McKinney
Provenance is the digital record of authorship: who made the diagnosis, when it was done, and what the impact of the diagnosis was on downstream care management.
ClinicalThiago Braga
Relevance means whether the study was right for the patient's condition, considering whether it was timely, actionable, and linked to an outcome.
ClinicalThiago Braga
Relevance is a much broader concept than appropriateness, which is related to a point in time (whether the exam was appropriate for the specific diagnosis or clinical picture).
ClinicalThiago Braga
Relevance must consider the upstream clinical concept and the downstream action during care that happened before and after the study was performed.
ClinicalThiago Braga
Pertinent positive findings are defined as findings that relate to something already in the clinical picture, not just those related directly to the reason for examination.
Clinical
A pulmonary nodule on a CT performed for appendicitis in a known smoker is a pertinent positive finding because it relates to other information in the patient's clinical record.
Clinical
Pertinent negative findings can help drive care forward, not just exclude a diagnosis.
Clinical
A negative cervical spine CT after trauma drives care forward by helping the patient be expedited for discharge from the emergency department without further care.
Clinical
Radiology has major impact even when a study is negative.
Opinion
An actionable incidental finding is defined as something truly unexpected and unrelated to all other items in a patient's medical history or documentation.
Clinical
A pulmonary nodule on an abdominal CT for appendicitis in a non-smoker is an actionable incidental finding, whereas in a smoker it would be a pertinent positive finding.
Clinical
For the last 35 years, the highest levels of efficacy (therapeutic choice, longitudinal patient outcomes, and societal benefit) have been out of reach despite many attempts, stuck as a conceptual dream due to lack of informatics tools.
OpinionElliot Siegel
The ACR committee's roadmap introduces concepts like diagnostic imaging provenance and the medical imaging life cycle to provide data-driven infrastructure bridging the gap between 1991 theory and modern practice.
ClinicalElliot Siegel
The framework enables tracking, proving, and elevating radiologist value across every level of the Fryback-Thornberry hierarchy.
OpinionElliot Siegel
The framework represents a transition from merely capturing a perfect image to having ownership of the patient's healthcare outcome.
OpinionElliot Siegel
The framework will help evaluate AI tools not just by accuracy but by how often they change something for the patient, including length of stay, long-term outcomes, and quality of life.
OpinionAlex McKinney
Fryback and Thornberry published a paper in 1991 challenging the medical community with a six-level hierarchical framework to evaluate the true efficacy of diagnostic imaging.
Host summaryElliot Siegel summarizing the discussion · not cited in answers
Fryback and Thornberry's framework includes level one (technical quality), level two (diagnostic accuracy), level three (impact on diagnostic thinking), level four (impact on therapeutic choice), level five (longitudinal patient outcomes), and level six (societal benefit).
Host summaryElliot Siegel summarizing the discussion · not cited in answers
GCMD Library — educational content from recorded physician discussions, not medical advice.