17 views 0 likes

Dr. CCHMC Pediatric Surgery

GCMD Space · View profile →

How Does the Blood Go Round in Single Ventricles and Fontans? New Horizons in...

Video Published 2019-01-11 Updated 2022-08-22

Timestops (8)

Topic Overview

Dr. Andrew Reddington discusses Fontan circulation physiology, emphasizing that 40-50% of cardiac output is driven by respiratory effort rather than the cardiac cycle. He presents evidence that systemic right ventricle morphology is not a short-term risk factor post-Fontan but may become significant after 20-30 years. The primary pathophysiology is diastolic dysfunction: early diastole is impaired by incoordinate ventricular relaxation, while late diastolic compliance progressively worsens with rising left atrial pressure. Pulmonary vascular resistance remains a critical determinant, with only half of adolescent Fontan patients showing vasodilator responsiveness to nitric oxide.

Key Takeaways

  • Respiratory effort drives 40-50% of Fontan cardiac output; mean airway pressure is critical to circuit flow. (2:43)
  • Only half of adolescent Fontan patients respond to nitric oxide; PDE5 inhibitors unlikely to add benefit. (4:52)
  • Fontan pathophysiology is diastolic: incoordinate relaxation impairs early filling; compliance worsens with rising LA pressure. (9:29)
  • Systemic RV morphology shows no short-term risk post-Fontan but may emerge as a factor after 20-30 years. (7:45)
  • Fontan ventricles are hypercontractile; the problem is diastolic dysfunction, not systolic failure. (8:22)

Inside this episode

Kai, the Library's AI content creator, listened to this episode and mapped who's speaking, the chapters, key claims, and cases. Every item links to the exact moment in the recording.

AI-enriched

Who's speaking

  • Grushin — host
  • Andrew Reddington — guest
  • Speaker 3 — host
  • Speaker 4 — guest
  • Speaker 5 — guest

Chapters

  • 0:00Respiratory-Driven Fontan Flow — Introduction and historical context of understanding Fontan physiology. Presentation of 1990 study showing respiratory effort drives 40-50% of cardiac output in Fontan circulation, with minimal cardiac cycle contribution.
  • 3:14Pulmonary Vascular Resistance and Vasodilator Response — Discussion of mean airway pressure effects on Fontan flow, Valsalva impact, and pulmonary vascular resistance. Presentation of nitric oxide study showing only 50% of adolescent Fontan patients demonstrate vasodilator responsiveness.
  • 6:10Right Ventricle as Non-Risk Factor — Evidence from multiple centers (CHOP, Boston, Melbourne) that systemic right ventricle morphology is not a short-term risk factor post-Fontan. Discussion of hypercontractile ventricular function in Fontan patients.
  • 9:29Diastolic Dysfunction Pathophysiology — Detailed presentation of diastolic impairment: early diastolic dysfunction from incoordinate relaxation, late diastolic compliance reduction, and pseudonormalization with rising left atrial pressure. Discussion of protein-losing enteropathy correlation.
  • 13:37Progressive Ventricular Compliance Deterioration — Eight-year follow-up data showing progressive diastolic stiffness, shortened IVRT, and faster E-wave deceleration. Pressure-volume analysis demonstrating abnormal diastolic compliance despite potentially normal end-diastolic pressure.
  • 16:29Panel Discussion — Questions addressing Valsalva effects, long-term right ventricle outcomes, and pathophysiology of diastolic dysfunction. Discussion of potential therapeutic targets including arterial impedance management and fibrosis.

Key claims

  • 2:4340-50% of cardiac output at baseline in Fontan patients is driven directly by the work of breathing — Andrew Reddington
  • 3:14Mean airway pressure makes the blood go round; negative pressure during normal ventilation draws blood into the Fontan circuit — Andrew Reddington
  • 3:28Valsalva maneuver at 20 cm H2O cuts off all spontaneous respiratory flow, leaving only tiny ventricular systole-driven flow — Andrew Reddington
  • 4:01Low pulmonary vascular resistance is a prerequisite for good Fontan outcome — Andrew Reddington
  • 4:52Nitric oxide caused approximately 1 indexed wood unit fall in pulmonary vascular resistance in Fontan patients — Andrew Reddington
  • 5:33Only half of adolescent Fontan patients showed benefit from nitric oxide — Andrew Reddington
  • 5:51If only half of patients benefit from nitric oxide, they are unlikely to further benefit from PDE5 inhibitors — Andrew Reddington
  • 6:54CHOP data showed no difference in 10-year outcomes between hypoplastic left heart syndrome and systemic left ventricle Fontan patients — Andrew Reddington
  • 7:22Boston data showed patients with systemic left ventricle or single right ventricle do better than all other diagnoses — Andrew Reddington
  • 7:45Melbourne data showed right ventricular dominance is a risk factor at birth, but after surviving the first couple years post-Fontan, survival curves are identical regardless of ventricular morphology — Andrew Reddington
  • 8:22Systemic ventricles in Fontan circulation are hypercontractile to match increased afterload — Andrew Reddington
  • 8:37Force-frequency relationships in systemic right and left ventricles in univentricular circulation outperformed normal ventricles — Andrew Reddington
  • 9:03End-systolic elastance in Fontan patients is orders of magnitude higher than normals and greater than systemic right ventricle in Mustard patients — Andrew Reddington
  • 9:29The problem in Fontan circulation is in diastole, not systole — Andrew Reddington
  • 10:06Early diastole (E wave) is affected post-Fontan, not late diastole (A wave), with virtual abolishment of early rapid filling — Andrew Reddington
  • 10:43Time constant of relaxation and isovolumic relaxation time are prolonged post-Fontan, indicating impaired ventricular relaxation — Andrew Reddington
  • 10:56Incoordinate wall motion during isovolumic relaxation causes early diastolic dysfunction, with some ventricular segments 180 degrees out of phase — Andrew Reddington
  • 12:23Longer isovolumic relaxation time correlates with longer hospital stay immediately post-Fontan — Andrew Reddington
  • 13:03Pseudonormalized E/A ratio in late post-operative Fontan patients indicates rising left atrial pressure with persistent incoordinate relaxation — Andrew Reddington
  • 13:36Left ventricular end-diastolic pressure rises by approximately 2 mmHg per decade after age 30 in normal individuals — Andrew Reddington
  • 14:18Eight-year follow-up showed Fontan patients maintained incoordinate relaxation but developed shortened IVRT (suggesting rising left atrial pressure) and faster E-wave deceleration (suggesting falling compliance) — Andrew Reddington
  • 15:06Diastolic compliance of Fontan ventricles (predominantly left) is highly abnormal compared to systemic right ventricles in Mustard patients — Andrew Reddington
  • 15:33Fontan patients can have normal left ventricular end-diastolic pressure despite profoundly abnormal ventricular compliance because reduced preload causes the ventricle to become smaller and pressure to fall — Andrew Reddington
  • 20:04PHN data on 500 Fontan patients showed systemic right ventricles have far more patients with increased E/E' ratio (indicating greater stiffness) compared to systemic left ventricles at 10-12 years post-Fontan — Andrew Reddington
  • 21:58End-diastolic pressure rise in normals is more rapid with hypertension, diabetes, other risk factors, and ventricular volume load — Andrew Reddington
  • 22:33Fontan patients frequently have volume load and raised arterial impedance/systemic vascular resistance — Andrew Reddington
  • 23:01Recent European conductance catheter work shows tight relationship between arterial elastance and ventricular end-diastolic pressure — Andrew Reddington
  • 23:18There is no evidence-based role for ACE inhibition in Fontan patients in the short term — Andrew Reddington
  • 23:38Management of left ventricular end-diastolic pressure, fibrosis, and vascular biology (not just systemic vasodilation) have potential as long-term therapeutic targets — Andrew Reddington
  • 23:58Understanding impact of long-term therapies will require 10-20 years of follow-up — Andrew Reddington
  • 19:32Mayo Clinic series with longer follow-up shows right ventricular morphology appears to be a risk factor late (beyond 20-30 years) — Speaker 4
  • 24:38Abnormalities in diastolic relaxation will likely become clinically manifest at 20-30 years, and we lack the long-term RV/LV data to know the answer — Speaker 5

Points of disagreement

  • 18:58Long-term significance of right ventricular morphology in Fontan patients
    • Andrew Reddington: Short-term data (10-15 years) shows no difference in outcomes between RV and LV morphology post-Fontan
    • Speaker 4: Mayo Clinic data with longer follow-up suggests RV morphology becomes a risk factor late
    • Speaker 5: Diastolic abnormalities will manifest clinically at 20-30 years; we lack sufficient long-term data to definitively answer whether RV morphology matters

Open questions

  • When does right ventricular morphology become a significant risk factor in Fontan patients—at what time point beyond 10-15 years?
  • What are the optimal therapeutic targets for managing progressive diastolic dysfunction in Fontan patients?
  • Should arterial vasodilators or agents targeting fibrosis be used long-term in Fontan patients, and how would we design trials with 10-20 year endpoints?
  • What percentage of Fontan patients would benefit from pulmonary vasodilators if only 50% respond to nitric oxide?
  • How can we identify which Fontan patients will develop clinically significant diastolic dysfunction at 20-30 years?
This episode was analyzed and enriched by Kai, the Library's AI content creator. Every item links to the moment it comes from — click a timestamp to listen in context.
Written for:

Why Fontan Circulation Depends on Breathing, Not Just the Heart

The episode's main topic retold as a plain-language walkthrough — what it is, why it matters, and what the speakers concluded. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For the care team · Explainer · AI-written, human-reviewed

The Problem That Made Fontan Necessary

Some children are born with only one functional ventricle — the heart cannot support both systemic and pulmonary circulations in the usual way. The Fontan procedure bypasses the problem by routing venous blood directly to the pulmonary arteries without passing through a pumping chamber. The superior and inferior vena cavae connect to the pulmonary arteries; the single ventricle pumps oxygenated blood to the body. This eliminates cyanosis but creates a circulation that operates on entirely different principles than the normal two-ventricle system.

How Blood Actually Moves in Fontan Circulation

For decades, clinicians assumed the single ventricle drove blood through the Fontan circuit the way a normal right ventricle does. It does not. Catheterization studies demonstrated that 40-50% of cardiac output at baseline is driven directly by the work of breathing 2:43. The cardiac cycle contributes minimally. Blood flow into the Fontan circuit mirrors respiratory effort, not ventricular contraction 3:14.

The mechanism is mean airway pressure. During normal inspiration, negative intrathoracic pressure draws blood into the pulmonary circuit. A Valsalva maneuver at 20 cm H₂O — the kind of strain produced by lifting heavy weight or straining at stool — cuts off nearly all spontaneous respiratory flow, leaving only a minimal pulse of blood driven by ventricular systole 3:28. "The Fontan circulation is one of the few situations where constipation can be fatal" [q2], Andrew Reddington noted in presenting this work.

This respiratory dependence requires extremely low pulmonary vascular resistance 4:01. The work of breathing generates only 2-3 cm H₂O of pressure; if pulmonary vascular resistance were elevated, that would be insufficient to drive flow. Nitric oxide studies in adolescent Fontan patients showed a fall of approximately 1 indexed Wood unit, but only half of patients demonstrated any vasodilator response 4:52 5:33. This has implications for chronic pulmonary vasodilator therapy: if only half respond to nitric oxide, further benefit from PDE5 inhibitors is unlikely 5:51.

The Ventricle Is Not the Weak Link

If a systemic right ventricle were going to fail, Fontan circulation — where it must sustain the entire systemic output against elevated afterload — would expose that weakness. It does not. Multiple registry analyses show that ventricular morphology is not a short-term risk factor. CHOP data found no difference in 10-year outcomes between hypoplastic left heart syndrome and systemic left ventricle Fontan patients 6:54. Boston data showed patients with systemic left or single right ventricles do better than all other diagnoses 7:22. Melbourne data confirmed that while right ventricular dominance carries risk at birth, survival curves after the first few post-Fontan years are identical regardless of morphology 7:45.

The reason is that Fontan ventricles are hypercontractile, not weak 8:22. Force-frequency studies using esophageal pacing showed that both systemic right and left ventricles in univentricular circulation outperformed normal ventricles 8:37. Direct measurement of end-systolic elastance — the gold standard for contractility — revealed values orders of magnitude higher than normal and greater than systemic right ventricles in Mustard patients 9:03. These ventricles pump hard against high resistance and couple reasonably well to their afterload.

Diastolic Dysfunction: The Actual Problem

The failure mode in Fontan circulation is diastolic, not systolic 9:29. Immediately post-Fontan, early diastolic filling (the E wave) is virtually abolished while late diastolic filling (the A wave) remains intact 10:06. The time constant of relaxation and isovolumic relaxation time are prolonged 10:43. The mechanism is incoordinate ventricular relaxation: some segments of the ventricular wall undergo post-systolic shortening during isovolumic relaxation, forcing other segments outward because blood is incompressible 10:56. MRI tagging has demonstrated segments 180 degrees out of phase with the rest of the ventricle — in systole while the rest of the chamber is in diastole. Longer isovolumic relaxation time correlates with longer hospital stay immediately post-Fontan 12:23.

This incoordination persists, but over time a second problem emerges: falling ventricular compliance. When the E/A ratio appears to normalize years after Fontan, it represents pseudonormalization — rising left atrial pressure compensating for worsening compliance and persistent incoordinate relaxation 13:03. Eight-year follow-up shows progressive diastolic stiffness: shortened isovolumic relaxation time (indicating rising left atrial pressure) and faster E-wave deceleration (indicating falling compliance) 14:18. Pressure-volume analysis confirms that diastolic compliance in Fontan ventricles, predominantly left, is profoundly abnormal compared even to systemic right ventricles in Mustard patients 15:06.

A critical point: Fontan patients can have normal left ventricular end-diastolic pressure despite severe diastolic stiffness 15:33. Reduced preload — there is no right ventricle to preload the left — causes the ventricle to operate lower on its pressure-volume curve. The chamber is smaller, pressure is lower, but compliance remains abnormal. This masks the severity of diastolic dysfunction on routine catheterization.

When Ventricular Morphology May Matter

In normal individuals, left ventricular end-diastolic pressure rises approximately 2 mmHg per decade after age 30 13:36. That rise accelerates with hypertension, diabetes, and volume load 21:58 — all of which Fontan patients experience. Recent data from the Pediatric Heart Network showed that at 10-12 years post-Fontan, systemic right ventricles have far more patients with elevated E/E′ ratios (indicating greater stiffness) than systemic left ventricles 20:04. Mayo Clinic series with longer follow-up suggest right ventricular morphology becomes a risk factor beyond 20-30 years 19:32. The question is not whether the right ventricle can sustain systemic output — it can — but whether it tolerates decades of progressive diastolic stiffening as well as a left ventricle does.

Implications for Referring Clinicians

Fontan patients are not simply "single ventricle patients." They have a circulation in which breathing drives half the cardiac output, pulmonary vascular resistance must remain near-normal, and progressive diastolic dysfunction is the dominant failure mode. Activities that produce sustained positive intrathoracic pressure — heavy lifting, Valsalva during bowel movements, certain resistance training — can acutely compromise pulmonary blood flow. Reddington notes that some patients find the resulting dizziness addictive, possibly due to endorphin release [q5], but sustained behavior of this kind is physiologically harmful.

Management of arterial impedance, volume load, and potentially fibrosis may represent therapeutic targets 23:38, though evidence for ACE inhibition or chronic vasodilators in the short term is lacking 23:18. Understanding the impact of long-term therapies will require 10-20 years of follow-up 23:58. Referral to a Fontan specialist is appropriate when there is unexplained exercise intolerance, new arrhythmia, protein-losing enteropathy, or any sign of ventricular dysfunction — but the dysfunction to watch for is diastolic, and it may not declare itself in end-diastolic pressure.

Takeaways from this story

  • Breathing drives 40-50% of Fontan cardiac output; Valsalva maneuvers can acutely compromise pulmonary blood flow.
  • Systemic right ventricle morphology is not a short-term risk factor post-Fontan; these ventricles are hypercontractile.
  • Fontan failure is diastolic: incoordinate relaxation abolishes early filling, and compliance progressively worsens over decades.
  • Normal end-diastolic pressure can mask severe diastolic dysfunction because reduced preload shifts the ventricle down its pressure-volume curve.
  • Only half of adolescent Fontan patients show vasodilator response to nitric oxide, limiting benefit from chronic PDE5 inhibitors.

Keywords

Hashtags

Transcript

Comments

Loading comments…