Journal of Pediatric Surgery Article Review: March 2023

Published: 2023-06-01

2 Views

0 Likes

0 Shares

0 Comments

StayCurrentMD

View profile →

Inside this episode

Kai, the Library's AI content creator, listened to this episode and mapped who's speaking, the chapters, key claims, and cases. Every item links to the exact moment in the recording.

AI-enriched

Who's speaking

Cecilia Gena — host
Speaker 2 — host
Mark Levitt — guest_expert
Speaker 4 — guest_expert

Chapters

0:04Introduction and Episode Overview — Research fellows introduce themselves and outline three colorectal pathology articles from the March 2023 JPS edition, selected with help from Dr. Mark Levitt.
1:27VACTERL and Gynecologic Anomalies in Anorectal Malformations — Discussion of a multi-center registry study examining the association between VACTERL anomalies and gynecologic anomalies in females with anorectal malformations, emphasizing the need for systematic gynecologic evaluation and multidisciplinary care.
4:52Sphincter Reconstruction for Post-Hirschsprung Incontinence — Review of a new surgical technique for reconstructing anal sphincters in patients with iatrogenic fecal incontinence following Hirschsprung pull-through, with early outcomes from 6 patients.
7:25Contrast Enema Utility Before Stoma Reversal — Retrospective Dutch study findings that routine contrast enemas before stoma reversal are only necessary for necrotizing enterocolitis patients, who have high stricture rates, rather than for all stoma reversals.
10:32Summary and Closing — Hosts recap the three articles and encourage listeners to follow on social media and download the Stay Current app.

Key claims

2:00VACTERL association is defined by at least 3 anomalies in the vertebral, anorectal, cardiac, tracheoesophageal, renal, or limb systems. — Speaker 2
2:15The study examined 834 females from the Pediatric Colorectal and Pelvic Learning Consortium (PCPLC) multi-center registry. — Speaker 2
2:24Patients with anorectal malformations and VACTERL association had more gynecologic anomalies, especially in recto-vestibular and recto-perineal fistulas. — Speaker 2
2:45In patients with anorectal malformations and VACTERL association, when one of the associated anomalies was in the renal system, there was an even higher risk of having an associated gynecological anomaly. — Speaker 2
3:49The first gynecology center for anorectal malformation patients was created in 2005 at Cincinnati Children's Hospital. — Mark Levitt
5:34The sphincter reconstruction technique addresses Hirschsprung patients who had iatrogenic injury at their original pull-through, with overstretched sphincters leaving them fecally incontinent. — Mark Levitt
5:53Sphincter reconstruction tightens the sphincters, allowing patients to feel stool coming and improve bowel control. — Speaker 2
6:14Of 6 patients who underwent sphincter reconstruction, 4 have done extremely well. — Mark Levitt
6:17Two patients with Down syndrome showed behavioral delay in their capacity to demonstrate successful bowel function and bowel control after sphincter reconstruction. — Mark Levitt
8:13The contrast enema study included 224 patients aged 3 years or younger who needed stoma reversal, conducted between 1998 and 2018 in the Netherlands. — Cecilia Gena
8:2310% of patients had strictures prior to stoma reversal, and 95% of those with strictures had necrotizing enterocolitis. — Cecilia Gena
8:46Only one stricture case was not in a necrotizing enterocolitis patient; it was in a patient treated for duodenal atresia who had subsequent volvulus with ischemic bowel injury. — Cecilia Gena
8:5768% of patients received a contrast enema, which detected 92% of strictures. — Cecilia Gena
9:07Most patients who develop strictures after stoma creation had problems in their vasculature, typically necrotizing enterocolitis patients. — Cecilia Gena
9:24Some patients have a chance of having two strictures, for instance with intestinal atresia, so if an atresia is found during antegrade enema, a retrograde enema should also be performed to check for a second stricture. — Cecilia Gena
9:47There is no mechanism to expect continuing disease or problems distal to a stoma that would require checking before stoma closure. — Mark Levitt
10:04There is a movement away from routine contrast studies in general, including not getting them in all patients who need a G-tube. — Speaker 4
10:15In patients with necrotizing enterocolitis, it is reasonable to get a contrast study before stoma takedown. — Speaker 4

Points of disagreement

6:47Clinical readiness to adopt sphincter reconstruction technique
- Speaker 2: The technique is promising for dealing with soiling after pull-through operations.
- Speaker 4: The numbers are too low to make a widespread practice change; would not change practice yet based on this paper despite the intriguing concept.

Open questions

What are the long-term outcomes of sphincter reconstruction in a larger patient cohort?
Should gynecologic anomalies be added as a separate component to the VACTERL acronym?
What is the optimal timing and method for detecting multiple strictures in patients with intestinal atresia before stoma reversal?

This episode was analyzed and enriched by Kai, the Library's AI content creator. Every item links to the moment it comes from — click a timestamp to listen in context.

Written for:

Gynecologic Evaluation in Anorectal Malformations: Why It Belongs in the VACTERL Workup

The episode's main topic retold as a plain-language walkthrough — what it is, why it matters, and what the speakers concluded. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For the care team · Explainer · AI-written, human-reviewed

Why This Matters

Anorectal malformations rarely occur in isolation 2:00. Most pediatric surgeons know to screen for VACTERL-associated anomalies — vertebral defects, cardiac lesions, tracheoesophageal fistula, renal dysplasia, limb abnormalities — but gynecologic pathology has historically been an afterthought, evaluated late or not at all 2:00. That gap matters because these patients carry substantial risk for Müllerian anomalies, ovarian pathology, and vaginal obstruction that can complicate reconstruction or cause harm if missed 2:24. The question this work addresses is whether gynecologic screening should be routine, and if so, for whom 4:28.

The Core Clinical Problem

Females with anorectal malformations, particularly those with VACTERL association, have a higher burden of gynecologic anomalies than previously recognized 2:24. The problem is not just prevalence but timing: many of these anomalies are clinically silent in infancy and early childhood, yet they influence surgical planning during anorectal reconstruction and can cause acute complications — hematocolpos, ovarian torsion, obstructed menstruation — if not identified before puberty 2:24. The traditional VACTERL workup does not systematically include pelvic imaging or gynecologic consultation, leaving a blind spot in an otherwise comprehensive evaluation 2:00.

The Evidence Base

A multi-center registry study examined 834 females with anorectal malformations enrolled in the Pediatric Colorectal and Pelvic Learning Consortium 2:15. Patients with VACTERL association had more gynecologic anomalies overall, with the association particularly strong in those with rectovesibular or rectal perineal fistulas 2:24. The risk was highest when renal anomalies were part of the VACTERL constellation — a finding that makes embryologic sense given the shared mesodermal origin of the urogenital and Müllerian systems 2:45.

The clinical implication is straightforward: any ARM patient should be considered for gynecologic evaluation 4:28. This is not a subspecialty curiosity; it is part of the baseline workup, as essential as echocardiography or renal ultrasound 4:28. The first dedicated gynecology center for ARM patients was established at Cincinnati Children's Hospital in 2005, and the model has since spread 3:49. The approach requires "gynecology brain power" — not just imaging, but expert interpretation and longitudinal follow-up [q2]. Müllerian anomalies can be subtle on neonatal imaging, and their significance often becomes clear only in the context of planned reconstruction 2:24.

How the Approach Works

Systematic gynecologic evaluation in ARM patients begins with pelvic ultrasound in infancy, ideally before or concurrent with anorectal reconstruction 4:28. The goal is to identify uterine duplication, vaginal septation, ovarian abnormalities, and any communication between the reproductive and urinary or gastrointestinal tracts 2:24. In patients with VACTERL association — particularly those with renal anomalies — MRI may be warranted for better anatomic detail 2:45.

The evaluation is not one-time 4:28. These patients need longitudinal follow-up through puberty, when previously occult pathology can declare itself 2:24. A multidisciplinary team approach is ideal, with gynecology colleagues integrated into the care plan from the outset 3:49. This is collaborative assessment, not a referral made when something goes wrong 4:28.

Gynecologic findings influence surgical decision-making 2:24. A patient with a duplicated vagina and rectovaginal fistula requires a different reconstructive approach than one with normal Müllerian anatomy 2:24. Obstructed hemivagina can mimic recurrent urinary tract infection or pelvic abscess if not recognized 2:24. The point is not to delay anorectal surgery, but to plan it with full knowledge of the pelvic anatomy 4:28.

Where Practice Remains Uncertain

The registry data establish association but do not yet define a screening algorithm 2:15. Should all ARM patients undergo pelvic imaging, or only those with VACTERL 4:28? Is ultrasound sufficient, or should MRI be routine in high-risk subgroups 2:45? The answers are not settled 4:28. What is clear is that the historical practice — evaluating gynecologic anatomy only when symptoms arise — misses too much 2:00.

There is also the question of what to do with incidental findings 2:24. Not every Müllerian variant requires intervention, and overtreatment carries its own risks 2:24. The expertise to distinguish clinically significant anomalies from benign variants is not uniformly available, which argues for centralization of care or at least access to subspecialty consultation 3:49.

When to Involve Gynecology

Any female with an anorectal malformation warrants gynecologic consideration 4:28. For patients with VACTERL association, particularly those with renal anomalies, systematic evaluation is not optional 2:45. The timing is early — ideally before definitive anorectal reconstruction — and the follow-up is long, extending through adolescence 4:28.

Referral is not just for imaging interpretation 3:49. Gynecology should be part of the multidisciplinary team from the beginning, contributing to surgical planning and anticipating future needs 3:49. As one discussant put it, gynecology deserves the same consideration in these patients as cardiology or nephrology [q1]. The evidence now supports that claim 2:15.

Takeaways from this story

Females with ARM and VACTERL association have higher rates of gynecologic anomalies, especially with renal involvement.
Systematic gynecologic evaluation should be part of the baseline ARM workup, not a late referral.
Multidisciplinary care including gynecology from the outset improves surgical planning and long-term outcomes.

Gynecologic Screening in ARM, Sphincter Reconstruction After Hirschsprung Pull-Through, and Selective Contrast Studies Before Stoma Reversal

The essential version of this episode — what it covers, the points that matter most, and what it changes for you. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For specialists · Core brief · AI-written, human-reviewed

Gynecologic anomalies in females with anorectal malformations

A multi-center registry analysis of 834 females with anorectal malformations found that patients with VACTERL association had higher rates of gynecologic anomalies, particularly those with rectovesibular and rectal perineal fistulas 2:24. When VACTERL association included a renal anomaly, the risk of gynecologic anomaly increased further 2:45. The implication: any ARM patient should be evaluated for gynecologic pathology 4:28, and multidisciplinary care should include gynecology expertise from the outset [q1][q2]. The first such center was established in 2005 at Cincinnati Children's Hospital 3:49.

Sphincter reconstruction for iatrogenic injury after Hirschsprung pull-through

A small case series describes sphincter reconstruction in 6 Hirschsprung patients left fecally incontinent after overstretched sphincters at their original pull-through 5:34[q3]. The technique tightens the sphincter complex to restore sensation and improve continence 5:53. Four patients did extremely well; two with Down syndrome showed behavioral delay in demonstrating bowel control 6:14 6:17. The procedure addresses an anatomic deficit that bowel management alone cannot solve 6:27.

One discussant noted the sample size is too small to justify widespread adoption 6:54[q4]. The concept is intriguing, but practice change awaits larger validation.

Contrast enema before stoma reversal: selective, not routine

A Dutch study of 224 pediatric stoma reversals (1998–2018) found strictures in 10% of patients, with 95% of those occurring in necrotizing enterocolitis cases 8:23 8:31. The single non-NEC stricture was in a duodenal atresia patient with subsequent volvulus and ischemic injury 8:46. Contrast enema detected 92% of strictures when performed (68% of patients) 8:57.

The mechanism is vascular: strictures form where ischemia occurred, typically in NEC 9:07. Some patients risk multiple strictures—if antegrade enema finds one, retrograde study may identify a second 9:24 9:32. One discussant argued there is no mechanism to expect ongoing distal pathology requiring routine imaging 9:47[q5]. The consensus: contrast studies are reasonable in NEC patients before stoma takedown 10:15, but not routine for all reversals 10:04.

Takeaways from this story

Females with ARM and VACTERL association—especially with renal anomalies—warrant systematic gynecologic evaluation.
Sphincter reconstruction may salvage continence after iatrogenic injury at Hirschsprung pull-through, but evidence remains limited.
Contrast enema before stoma reversal is indicated for NEC patients, not routinely for all etiologies.

Gynecologic Screening in ARM Patients, Sphincter Reconstruction for Hirschsprung Incontinence, and Selective Contrast Studies Before Stoma Reversal

The essential version of this episode — what it covers, the points that matter most, and what it changes for you. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For trainees · Core brief · AI-written, human-reviewed

Gynecologic anomalies in females with anorectal malformations

A multi-center registry study of 834 females with anorectal malformations found that patients with VACTERL association had more gynecologic anomalies, particularly those with rectovesibular and rectal perineal fistulas 2:24. VACTERL is defined by at least three anomalies across vertebral, anorectal, cardiac, tracheoesophageal, renal, or limb systems 2:00. When one of the associated anomalies was in the renal system, the risk of gynecologic anomaly was even higher 2:45.

The first gynecology center for ARM patients was established in 2005 at Cincinnati Children's Hospital 3:49. Mark Levitt argues that "gynecology is a key member and it should be considered as worthy of consideration, as worthy of being evaluated as problems with the vertebral column, problems with the cardiac system, problems with the renal" [q1]. Any ARM patient should be evaluated for potential gynecologic problems 4:28.

Sphincter reconstruction after Hirschsprung pull-through

A small case series describes sphincter reconstruction for Hirschsprung patients who developed fecal incontinence from iatrogenic sphincter injury during their original pull-through, where sphincters were overstretched 5:34. The reconstruction tightens the sphincters, allowing patients to feel stool and improve bowel control 5:53. Of six patients, four did extremely well; two with Down syndrome showed behavioral delay in demonstrating successful bowel control 6:14 6:17.

This addresses an anatomic problem that bowel management alone cannot solve 6:27. However, one discussant noted the sample size is too low to justify widespread practice change 6:54, calling the concept intriguing but not yet practice-changing [q4].

Contrast enemas before stoma reversal

A Dutch study of 224 patients under age three needing stoma reversal found that 10% had strictures, and 95% of those with strictures had necrotizing enterocolitis 8:23 8:31. The single non-NEC case was a duodenal atresia patient who developed volvulus with ischemic bowel injury 8:46. Contrast enema detected 92% of strictures 8:57.

Most strictures occur in patients with vascular problems, typically NEC 9:07. There is no mechanism to expect continuing disease distal to a stoma in other conditions 9:47[q5]. The discussants noted a broader movement away from routine contrast studies toward disease-specific indications 10:04, with contrast enemas before stoma reversal reasonable specifically for NEC patients 10:15.

Takeaways from this story

Females with ARM and VACTERL association, especially with renal anomalies, warrant systematic gynecologic evaluation.
Sphincter reconstruction may help Hirschsprung patients with iatrogenic incontinence, but evidence remains limited.
Contrast enema before stoma reversal is indicated for NEC patients, not routinely for all stoma closures.
Most post-stoma strictures occur in patients with vascular injury, particularly necrotizing enterocolitis.

Topic overview

Three research fellows from Cincinnati Children's Hospital review three articles from the March 2023 Journal of Pediatric Surgery, focusing on colorectal pathology. The discussion covers: (1) the association between VACTERL anomalies and gynecologic anomalies in females with anorectal malformations, particularly when renal anomalies are present; (2) a new sphincter reconstruction technique for iatrogenic fecal incontinence following Hirschsprung pull-through procedures, with early promising results in 4 of 6 patients; and (3) evidence that routine contrast enemas before stoma reversal are only necessary for necrotizing enterocolitis patients, who have a 95% rate of stricture formation, rather than for all stoma reversals.

Key takeaways

Females with anorectal malformations, VACTERL, and renal anomalies have highest risk for gynecologic anomalies—screen systematically. (2:24)
Sphincter reconstruction for iatrogenic Hirschsprung injury shows promise: 4/6 patients improved; behavioral factors affect outcomes. (5:34)
Routine contrast enemas before stoma reversal only needed for NEC patients—95% stricture rate vs. rare in other etiologies. (8:23)
When intestinal atresia found on antegrade enema, perform retrograde study—some patients harbor two strictures. (9:24)

Keywords

anorectal malformations VACTERL association gynecologic anomalies Hirschsprung disease fecal incontinence necrotizing enterocolitis strictures Down syndrome duodenal atresia volvulus intestinal atresia pull-through sphincter reconstruction stoma reversal contrast enema

Hashtags

Hashtags will be added soon through AI processing

Transcript

Click "Show Transcript" to view the full text (9787 characters)

Hello, everyone. Welcome back to another installment in our series. I'm Cecilia Gena. I'm Ellen Ancisco. And I'm, I'm Tom Bash. And we are research fellows at Cincinnati Children's Hospital, and along with Stay Current, we are sharing knowledge to improve child health around the globe. So, today we are reviewing the March edition of JPS and for that, we have 3 articles that the editor helped us choose. Doctor Mark Levitt from Children's National Hospital helped us choose these articles. Hi, this is Mark Levitt. I'm the chief of colorectal and pelvic reconstruction at Children's National Hospital, Washington DC. The articles are listed and linked in the description below. Follow along and read with us. Great. Uh, for today's episode, we have 3 articles about colorectal. pathology. The first one is about bacterial association with gynecologic anomalies. The second one is about a new technique for the pus anal sphincter after a pull-through for Hirschsprung disease. And the third one is about contrast enema patients prior to stoma reversal. So let's start. So, the first article is, does presence of a veal anomaly predict an associated gynecologic anomaly in females with inner rectum malformations? And we talked to the first author, Doctor Hira Ahmad. Hi, my name is Hira Ahmad, and I'm a senior fellow at Seattle Children's Hospital. Essentially, they wanted to see if females with interectal malformations or ARMs. And veal anomaly, were more likely to have gynecologic anomalies. And as a reminder, Vactal is an association defined by at least 3 anomalies in the vertebral, inner ectal, cardiac, tracheoesophageal, renal, or limb systems. To study our question, we looked at the multi-center registry of the pediatric colorectal and pelvic. Consortium or PCPLC. And overall, they looked at 834 females, and they found that there was an association and that more of the patients with ARMs and bacterial association had gynecologic anomalies, and this was especially true for the recto vestibular and rectal perineal fistulas. And even more interesting was the fact that in patients who had ARM who did have a bacter association, When one of the associate anomalies was in the renal system, there was an even higher risk of having an associated gynecological anomaly. Gynecology is a key member and it should be considered as worthy of consideration, as worthy of being evaluated as problems with the vertebral column, problems with the cardiac system, problems with the renal. System. And that was Doctor Mark Levitt. He was the editor who helped us choose these articles. I think it's really important to realize that besides cloaca, rectal perineal and recto vestibular fistulas in these patients also has an association with gynecologic anomalies, so we have to start looking for them so we can assess the patients the best way possible. You know, this concept of the gynecologic association with an anorectal malformation is relatively new. It really was launched in 2005. With the creation of the first ever Kent at Cincinnati Children's Hospital, I'm very proud that um Alberto and I launched a program in Cincinnati, and I will be grateful to Cincinnati Children's. A multidisciplinary team approach is ideal when we care for ARM patients, and this should include Our gynecology colleagues, um, to provide a systematic and collaborative assessment for, um, any patients who are undergoing reconstruction of anal rectal malformation. You need gynecology brain power to influence the care of these patients. And this paper really points out that any ARM patient must considered whether or not there's a gynecologic problem to be found and treated. That's why it's so important. And here's what Todd had to say. So it might need its separate letter in the in the acronym. Our second article of the day is reconstructing the anal sphincters to reverse hydrogenic overstretching following a pull-through for Hirstprung disease. This is a paper of a technique that I described a year ago. These are the first year outcomes. We talked to the first author, Elizabeta Bokawa. My name is Elizabeta Bowaan. I was a Research fellow at Children's National and I'm currently doing my research at Children's Mercy Hospital, and this is a paper from Children's National Hospital. In this paper, they wanted to see the outcomes with the new surgical technique for the patients who had pulled through for Hirschsprung disease having soiling. These are Hirschprung's patients who had iatrogenic injury at their original pull-through. Their sphincters were overstretched, and they were left fecally incontinent. That was Doctor Mark Levitt. He's the editor that picked this article this month. He's also the senior author in this paper. By sphincter reconstruction, the sphincters are tightened. Which allows the patients to feel the stool coming and therefore improve their bowel control. So, basically, what they do is attach the sphincter complex to the bowel wall so that it closes better. Of 6 patients, 4 have done extremely well. 2 have Down syndrome, so I think there's a behavioral delay in their capacity to demonstrate successful bowel function and bowel control. This procedure allows these patients to get the solution of their anatomic problem that cannot be solved just with bowel management. So the technique is new. Results show us the sphincter reconstruction can be promising dealing with soiling after the poultry operation. I trust that these authors see it more than anyone, so they know that they can probably identify when there's a patulus anus and it's, and this. This patient deserves to have this procedure, but I think these numbers are too low for us to be making a widespread practice change. I think it's an intriguing concept, but I would not change my practice yet based on this paper. So this is interesting. I think it'll be interesting to see, you know, more patients outcomes. Obviously, this was a small sample, but still interesting to hear about more patients in the future. Now, the third article is routine contrast enema Prior to stoma reversal Si only required following treatment for necrotizing enterocolitis, an evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy of the contrast enema. This is a retrospective study done in the Netherlands and we talked to two of the first Authors. My name is Robert, and I finished med school almost a year ago. I'm working, uh, as a resident in the gynecology and obstetrician, and I did some research with my brother. Yeah, my name is Lauren Saroteer. I did my, uh, PhD at the pediatric Surgery department of the Amsterdam UMC and afterwards, I got accepted to do specialization to try. medicine, which I'm doing right now in Omelo in the Zerete Hospital. This study was between 1998 and 2018, and they looked at patients 3 years old or younger that needed a stoma reversal. Uh look at if they got a contrast enema, uh, how many weeks before, uh, was it, uh, uh, ontrograde or retrograde. And they had 224 patients included, and of them, 10% had strictures prior to the reversal, and 95% of them had had neck or necrotizing enterocolitis. Just one of the strictures wasn't in the neck patient. And it was a patient treated for a duodenal atresia, which had a vulvulus afterwards, so there was an ischemic injury as well of the bowel. Of all the patients, only 68% had a chondrocinema and detected 92% of the strictures, so it's really accurate. But also, one of the conclusions is that most of the patients that are going to have a stricture after the creation of the stoma are patients that had problems in their vasculature, so those patients are probably patients that had neck. And what else we found was that in some patients, there is a chance of having two strictures, for instance, if you have an intestinal atresia. So that's why we set out that if you find an atresia during, for instance, intrograde enema, you could also perform a retrograde enema to be sure that's not, there's not a second stricture which we found in one patient. And I agree with that wholeheartedly. I don't think there's any mechanism to expect that distal to your stoma, there is continuing disease or continuing problem that you need to check for before you close the stoma. And again, that was Doctor Mark Levitt. What we're seeing is a movement away from routine contrast studies in general. You know, we don't necessarily get them in all patients who need a G tube. Now we're realizing we don't need it in all stoma reversals. It's very tailored to the specific disease, and I think it makes sense, especially after this paper validating it, that in patients with necrotizing enterocolitis, it's reasonable to get a contrast study before stoma takedown. OK. So, those were the three articles for today. The first one was about gynecologic anomalies in bacterial association, and we found out that it's really important to look for them in female patients with bacterial. The second one was about this new technique for the Puss anal sphincter in Hirschsprun disease, and even though we have a small sample, it seems promising, so we are going to keep an eye on that. And the third one was about routine contrast enema for stoma reversal, and it seems that it is only useful in patients that had neck. If you liked this episode, don't forget to follow us on social media, subscribe to our YouTube channel, listen to previous episodes of this podcast or other podcasts, wherever you get your podcast from, and don't forget to download the Steak or an app or an App Store or Play Store. OK, so until then, I'm Cecilia Gena. I'm Ellen Ancisco. And I'm, I'm Tom Bash. And we are research fellows at Cincinnati Children's Hospital, and along with Stay Current, we are sharing knowledge to improve child health around the globe.

Comments

Loading comments...