Hepatoblastoma
Topic overview
Expert discussion on hepatoblastoma diagnosis and management in children, covering differential diagnosis of pediatric liver masses, role of alpha-fetoprotein testing, and surgical decision-making for biopsy versus upfront resection. Emphasizes age-specific considerations and proper biopsy technique to avoid tumor seeding.
Timestops
0:07
Stay Current is a multimedia publication designed to keep he…
Stay Current is a multimedia publication designed to keep healthcare professionals up to date with standards of care and…
0:30
This is Todd Ponsky with State Current and Pediatric Surgery
This is Todd Ponsky with State Current and Pediatric Surgery, and today we are broadcasting live from Akron Children's H…
0:55
You know
You know, Max, this is a tough thing for a lot of us because many of us don't see this very often. So this is a particul…
1:23
They
They, they had an abdominal mass that mom noticed, and they get a CAT scan and they see a large liver mass. How do you a…
1:53
So a one year old is likely to be a hepatoblastoma
So a one year old is likely to be a hepatoblastoma, although there are other malignancies that can occur that young, inc…
2:19
You know
You know, the and hepatoblastoma presents from the first year of life through perhaps 10 years of age, although there ar…
2:43
We'll talk a little bit later on about pretext and so forth
We'll talk a little bit later on about pretext and so forth, but if, if this is a rhabdoid tumor, chemotherapy is not im…
3:07
But let's say that it's a large mass that the surgeon's not …
But let's say that it's a large mass that the surgeon's not comfortable with excising with a good margin. Then the next …
3:37
where Chris Walden has looked at some of the biopsy things.
where Chris Walden has looked at some of the biopsy things. In general, most people favor needle biopsy of the liver rat…
4:06
Want to cross the left lobe of the liver if the left lobe do…
Want to cross the left lobe of the liver if the left lobe doesn't have tumor in it because poblastoma will seed and it c…
4:36
Talk to me about what else would be in your differential at …
Talk to me about what else would be in your differential at different ages. What about a newborn or a 6 month old? Sure,…
4:57
The other malignancy that is more common in very young child…
The other malignancy that is more common in very young children is rhabdoid tumor, which is a small blue round cell tumo…
5:23
So there's a variety of both benign and malignant lesions
So there's a variety of both benign and malignant lesions, hepatocys. Cellular carcinomas can occur in young children. U…
5:50
But for most patients with hepatocellular carcinoma
But for most patients with hepatocellular carcinoma, you're going to see those children later on in life. There is a mix…
6:17
So when you're Developing your differential diagnosis
So when you're Developing your differential diagnosis, you need a good history, good physical look over things, you know…
6:39
But if you
But if you, if you've got an isolated liver tumor in a 1 year old, the most common diagnosis is going to be a hepatoblas…
7:08
Well, you know, probably I think those diagnoses are there.
Well, you know, probably I think those diagnoses are there. Again, I think that you have to look at the totality. Alpha …
7:29
And so there's normal nomograms that you can follow.
And so there's normal nomograms that you can follow. So that's a super helpful test even in a newborn and there is a pre…
7:59
Oh, that's interesting, OK.
Oh, that's interesting, OK. So I want to go back then so we're, before I interrupted you, so you have this child, it's a…
8:27
Exactly right
Exactly right, and I would encourage all of our listeners to to become involved with the children's psychology group in …
8:52
The for the biology arm of the children's oncology group
The for the biology arm of the children's oncology group, they want 10 core biopsies, so we're not talking about just on…
9:16
But you just have to recognize the complication rate and in …
But you just have to recognize the complication rate and in fact some mortality seems higher with open biopsies than it …
9:41
surgery
surgery, oncology, interventional radiology ought to be on board and talk through the plans, and I would do that in cons…
10:08
OK
OK, so your child then has a, a needle biopsy, let's say it's, it doesn't look like it's resectable up front and actuall…
10:27
So
So, uh, the most important thing for everybody to take home from this podcast, Todd, is that the overarching goal of tre…
10:46
And
And, and so when we're talking about safe resection, most of the folks who I work with and have had the privilege of bei…
11:09
And it actually talks about and Chris Weldon and Greg have s…
And it actually talks about and Chris Weldon and Greg have set up really nice surgical resection guidelines in consultat…
11:38
Mhm so let's talk about that now then can you explain in mor…
Mhm so let's talk about that now then can you explain in more detail the pretext system? Yeah, so the pretext system is …
12:05
But the bottom line is that Quino recognized that the Liver …
But the bottom line is that Quino recognized that the Liver anatomy was reasonably constant. For those of you who like t…
12:26
So it doesn't make a lot of sense to people until you know t…
So it doesn't make a lot of sense to people until you know that, but the caudate lobe, which is segment one, which is be…
12:50
Yeah
Yeah, so anyway, a pretext 1 lesion has three contiguous sectors of the liver that are free. So the only way you have a …
13:17
A pretext 2 is 2 adjoining sectors free.
A pretext 2 is 2 adjoining sectors free. That can happen. Three ways you can have a right sided lesion with the left hem…
13:42
So you've got those two that are joining free.
So you've got those two that are joining free. So with pretext 3, there is only one sector free of disease, and there ar…
14:00
And in pretext for all of the sectors are involved
And in pretext for all of the sectors are involved, so there are no sectors of the liver that are free of disease, you k…
14:25
And it's more common for people to overread pretext and unde…
And it's more common for people to overread pretext and underread, but in order to have a study that allows you to evalu…
14:48
And in the new FIT trial
And in the new FIT trial, we have said it was OK to do an upfront resection if it was a conventional hemihepatectomy or …
15:13
So if this is a lesion that is on the baby's left lateral se…
So if this is a lesion that is on the baby's left lateral sector and you can do a left hepatectomy and it's just one les…
15:40
There is no need for any chemotherapy at all
There is no need for any chemotherapy at all, and survival in that instance is 100%. And you have to make sure that it i…
16:01
But the deal is if it's a safe resection
But the deal is if it's a safe resection, you can limit the toxicity of therapy overall by decreasing the chemotherapy n…
16:25
So I think that that is a question that has Become increasin…
So I think that that is a question that has Become increasingly well defined, if you will. And so in the FI protocol, an…
16:52
But with a pretext one disease
But with a pretext one disease, the surgical guidelines as they stand right now, you have to look for metastatic disease…
17:21
So if you have a pretext 1 lesion with what appears to be a …
So if you have a pretext 1 lesion with what appears to be a metastatic disease in the lungs, that's a high risk patient.…
17:45
If there are no involvement of the vena cava
If there are no involvement of the vena cava, the confluence of the hepatic veins, or the portal vein, and the surgeon j…
18:11
If the if the lesion is not resectable for some reason
If the if the lesion is not resectable for some reason, the surgeon is not comfortable with it, then you biopsy, go to c…
18:35
That's sitting right on the cava that
That's sitting right on the cava that, you know, is pushing the cava and you don't think there's any margin between that…
19:05
That moves that patient into a higher risk environment.
That moves that patient into a higher risk environment. So age is a factor in doing this risk assignment. But there's a …
19:33
The patient comes in
The patient comes in, they've got a CT that let's say it looks like it's a resectable tumor, and I want to just make cle…
20:03
So
So, so the pretext system that we went over that talks about which sectors are free. How many adjoining sectors are free…
20:30
And when we're talking about upfront resection
And when we're talking about upfront resection, we're talking about lesions that have no annotation. Factors, OK, but le…
21:00
And V3
And V3, which is a particularly problematic area, is that there is evidence of tumor thrombus that extends out of that v…
21:27
So in a patient that presents with an annotation they're not…
So in a patient that presents with an annotation they're not going to be getting an upfront resection, correct? OK. So i…
21:58
That's correct, OK.
That's correct, OK. So if they have, and we'll take these different situations, if they have a pretext 1 with no annotat…
22:27
Can you go over the different histologic subtypes?
Can you go over the different histologic subtypes? Well, I am for sure not an expert and. Different histologic subtypes,…
22:54
The most common adverse finding is patients that have small …
The most common adverse finding is patients that have small cell undifferentiated or STU, but small cell undifferentiate…
23:12
All blue cell morphology with high nuclear cytoplasmic ratio…
All blue cell morphology with high nuclear cytoplasmic ratio and the pathologist, and there is a lot of immunohistochemi…
23:38
There is macular trabecular or pleomorphic are descriptors t…
There is macular trabecular or pleomorphic are descriptors that are used for this, so with other epithelial components. …
23:50
So
So, so having a good pathologist who really knows this and and even at Saint Jude and and Labana we frequently get secon…
24:20
Uh, fetal and embryonal subtype.
Uh, fetal and embryonal subtype. What happens to that patient? That patient will get chemotherapy and, and, and AHE 0731…
24:41
That manuscript is in preparation
That manuscript is in preparation, but the results with just two courses of cisplatin-based chemotherapy after upfront r…
25:09
That
That, yeah, I certainly wouldn't put in a port or a long term line. You may want to have a central line for the resectio…
25:35
it depend on how, how you're set up and.
it depend on how, how you're set up and. or wherever our listeners are. So if, if the diagnosis is apatoblastoma, the ch…
26:04
If it's not going to be resectable or there's any question i…
If it's not going to be resectable or there's any question it's not going to be resectable, we encourage people to refer…
26:31
Olivon and a number of other folks have shown that most of t…
Olivon and a number of other folks have shown that most of the bang that you're going to get with shrinkage of the tumor…
26:59
So you get completely resected with 6 rounds of therapy on
So you get completely resected with 6 rounds of therapy on, Exactly the template that's laid out in Ahab 0731 or the sur…
27:14
If it's a multifocal tumor
If it's a multifocal tumor, I would urge all multifocal tumors to be referred to transplantation because I've had a mult…
27:39
So multifocal tumors
So multifocal tumors, I would urge people to send them straight away to a transplant center. That's a great summary ther…
28:08
You need to have a high quality CT scan or MRI.
You need to have a high quality CT scan or MRI. But you know your capabilities, the OR capabilities. I know mine. I refe…
28:27
I refer them to somebody else to do transplants now.
I refer them to somebody else to do transplants now. So it's not a defeat. It's just like you just need to know what you…
28:43
I think that's a great point.
I think that's a great point. So Max, what other risk factors are important in developing a treatment roadmap? So Todd, …
29:06
But there are children that develop these tumors when they'r…
But there are children that develop these tumors when they're older, and a child that is 6 years of age or older with he…
29:31
And a premature baby with a bad case of bronchopulmonary dys…
And a premature baby with a bad case of bronchopulmonary dysplasia is going to be a higher risk surgical patient for sur…
29:53
They are involvement of vessels that will get you to interme…
They are involvement of vessels that will get you to intermediate or high risk, and then children who are 8 years of age…
30:18
So if the patient has a hepatoblastoma
So if the patient has a hepatoblastoma, but the alpha fetoprotein is less than 100, that patient's going to be a high ri…
30:44
And again to reiterate
And again to reiterate, those are high risk biologic patients, not necessarily high risk from a surgical standpoint, but…
31:01
So the pulmonary metastases are not good news
So the pulmonary metastases are not good news, but you can have superb results with that, and the current AHEP results a…
31:24
In a similar way
In a similar way, there are going to be kids that have some pulmonary mets, biopsy them, you initiate chemotherapy, and …
31:53
A child where the mets get smaller but hang out is going to …
A child where the mets get smaller but hang out is going to need a pulmonary metastectomy, and that can be done with a t…
32:17
Interestingly
Interestingly, the Japanese have published using endocyanine green as a marker for thoracoscopic things because that is …
32:35
And the bottom line is that if the mets don't disappear
And the bottom line is that if the mets don't disappear, you want to get them biopsied to confirm that in fact they are …
33:05
You're going to go in and biopsy that, right?
You're going to go in and biopsy that, right? Not just treat. You're going to confirm that that's a metastatic hepatolas…
33:29
It's going to drive chemotherapy decision making
It's going to drive chemotherapy decision making, and there's going to be a big difference in the chemotherapy decision …
33:57
Yeah, it's almost the same thing, the excisional biopsy, so.
Yeah, it's almost the same thing, the excisional biopsy, so. All right, so this patient had a pretext 1, but they had a …
34:11
You basically removed it
You basically removed it, so that gets confusing because you're going to treat with chemo and, and you probably won't se…
34:38
So from a biologic standpoint
So from a biologic standpoint, that's a high risk tumor and needs to have high risk chemotherapy. Got it. So it's an ind…
34:48
So you do the biopsy
So you do the biopsy, you treat with your two rounds of chemo. your cisplatin-based chemo, you reimage the chest, you do…
35:08
A metastatic lesion in the lung is going to get a total of 6…
A metastatic lesion in the lung is going to get a total of 6 courses of chemotherapy, and you would like to have them re…
35:37
I usually stage them.
I usually stage them. I usually do the liver resection and then go back and do the pulmonary, uh, work at a later date. …
35:52
Actually in the operating room
Actually in the operating room, what maneuvers can improve the safety and the success of the liver resection? Yeah, so y…
36:16
You get into the abdomen and there are no contraindications …
You get into the abdomen and there are no contraindications that are obvious, and so you're a go. I would strongly urge …
36:45
The next thing I would say is that before I do anything of c…
The next thing I would say is that before I do anything of consequence with the liver, I make sure I can vascularly isol…
37:15
Same thing at the suprarenal infrahepatic.
Same thing at the suprarenal infrahepatic. vena cava. So just above the right renal vein, dissect out the vena cava, get…
37:38
You don't have to dissect out the port of hepati.
You don't have to dissect out the port of hepati. But if there is anything anatomically that would keep you from doing a…
38:05
Because the vena cava is going to be a low pressure system.
Because the vena cava is going to be a low pressure system. You get a big bunch of air in through a hole in the vein tha…
38:27
I would say that in all of this
I would say that in all of this, the team is really important and multidisciplinary care is really important, and that e…
38:52
You want to use
You want to use, and this is, there are several references in the literature, but you want to use a hypovolemic type of …
39:19
Do this operation with vascular control
Do this operation with vascular control, a low CVP, and really good knowledge of the anatomy based on ultrasound that's …
39:46
And, and you want to use anatomic resections.
And, and you want to use anatomic resections. I am not a fan of non-anatomic resections. There are occasions when a non-…
40:08
I like a little handheld harmonic.
I like a little handheld harmonic. The adult guys use for doing thyroidectomies. It's fast. Hemostasis is excellent. You…
40:17
The Cusa is really good for dissecting around veins and clea…
The Cusa is really good for dissecting around veins and clearing up your anatomy, but doesn't provide any hemostasis. Bu…
40:47
Then take the outflow for the segment you're taking before I…
Then take the outflow for the segment you're taking before I get to that. Then I do the parenchymal dissection. OK, so y…
41:06
The problem in babies is that the width of the stapler is wi…
The problem in babies is that the width of the stapler is wider than the margin is sometimes, and you can get it crushed…
41:36
Or right portal bundle, and I've used staplers.
Or right portal bundle, and I've used staplers. If the margin's not a problem, you can swing all the way around bile duc…
41:57
So what is the role for vascular reconstruction or extreme r…
So what is the role for vascular reconstruction or extreme resection in the treatment of hetoblastoma? We don't know is …
42:27
It comes at the expense of requiring lifelong immunosuppress…
It comes at the expense of requiring lifelong immunosuppression and problems down the road with potential for rejection,…
42:44
An extreme operation which I have done a fair number of and …
An extreme operation which I have done a fair number of and like where you are resecting the cava to get a cava margin a…
43:07
Oncologic results to transplant without the immunosuppressio…
Oncologic results to transplant without the immunosuppression, and this is unpublished data, but something that I am, as…
43:34
So I think that the key deal that we don't know are truly
So I think that the key deal that we don't know are truly, you know, again overriding take home message here is that tre…
44:00
Which is best is going to depend on late effects for transpl…
Which is best is going to depend on late effects for transplant that include rejection and secondary malignancies. For e…
44:20
I think that in general the best folks to make those decisio…
I think that in general the best folks to make those decisions are people who can do either one of them, and they will b…
44:47
Having a grossly positive margin
Having a grossly positive margin, getting into an operation and leaving gross residual disease behind is not acceptable.…
45:00
0731 or fit or you know that shouldn't happen
0731 or fit or you know that shouldn't happen, but it has happened and and the place where it happens most often are in …
45:30
So there are two places that kids relapse
So there are two places that kids relapse, either relapse locally in the liver or they relapse in the lungs. If they hav…
45:51
Now
Now, having said that, I've had people who have had multiple local recurrences in the same spot that have gotten sent to…
46:19
So radiation for hepatoblastoma has not been explored a whol…
So radiation for hepatoblastoma has not been explored a whole lot, and I know of very Almost no anecdotal data of it bei…
46:40
And let's say you've done this after they've done 4 rounds o…
And let's say you've done this after they've done 4 rounds of chemotherapy, you've done your resection, and you have cle…
47:08
And I want to make sure that in the beginning I want to make…
And I want to make sure that in the beginning I want to make sure I was using the right terminology. So I kept referring…
47:29
Including the whole
Including the whole, the whole treatment plan, including chemotherapy and everything, is that correct? No, I think prete…
47:55
So upfront resection before chemotherapy is pretext 1 or 2.
So upfront resection before chemotherapy is pretext 1 or 2. After a child has been said we're not eligible for upfront c…
48:18
After 4 courses of chemotherapy
After 4 courses of chemotherapy, whether it's a pretext 23, has annotation factors, whatever, the surgeon's job is to re…
48:44
Now in the US
Now in the US, for pretext for an AHE 0731, we transplanted about 90% of those patients. But, but the fact that a patien…
49:11
It's pretext 3
It's pretext 3, you've only got one free sector, so it's either going to be the left lateral sector or the right posteri…
49:37
And
And, and again, if you do your upfront chemotherapy and they still look unresectable, that's when you would refer them t…
49:53
It can go up much higher
It can go up much higher, but once you get above 8 years of age, your, your risk goes up. The plan is to get an AFP leve…
50:16
It's dealer's choice if you want to get a biopsy in the begi…
It's dealer's choice if you want to get a biopsy in the beginning of that pulmonary met to confirm that it is actually a…
50:45
If after 2 to 4 rounds of chemotherapy.
If after 2 to 4 rounds of chemotherapy. Therapy, it still looks unresectable, then you should probably refer to a transp…
51:13
So there's kind of very low risk histology which is well dif…
So there's kind of very low risk histology which is well differentiated pure fetal. Most histologies are kind of in the …
51:37
The technique you like to use to come through the parenchyma
The technique you like to use to come through the parenchyma, you prefer to use the harmonic, and there's some talk now …
52:06
I can tell you
I can tell you, Max, and I'll let you have the last word here, but I can tell you that this has been wonderful for me. W…
52:29
I appreciate your getting this information out to everybody.
I appreciate your getting this information out to everybody. Just want to emphasize that the children's psychology group…
52:48
These are wonderful resources
These are wonderful resources, and most of the tumors that I see and take care of, I send out questions to Rebecca Myers…
53:14
So I would encourage surgeons who are seeing patients who ar…
So I would encourage surgeons who are seeing patients who are interested in participating in this to be involved with th…
53:41
So again
So again, I want to thank you very much for taking time out of your day to do this chapter and we hopefully if we have q…
54:09
Please send questions or comments to us attacurrent podcast@…
Please send questions or comments to us attacurrent podcast@gmail.com. We'll see you next time.
Key takeaways
- Elevated alpha-fetoprotein in a 1-year-old with liver mass strongly suggests hepatoblastoma; AFP testing is crucial for diagnosis.
- Needle biopsy should traverse normal liver tissue that will be resected; avoid crossing tumor-free left lobe to prevent seeding.
- Rhabdoid tumor is a critical differential in young children; it requires upfront resection as chemotherapy is ineffective.
- Hepatocellular carcinoma in young children often associates with inborn errors of metabolism, particularly tyrosinemia.
- Very low-risk hepatoblastoma may warrant upfront resection without biopsy; large masses require biopsy before neoadjuvant therapy.
Keywords
Hashtags
Transcript
Click "Show Transcript" to view the full text (46471 characters)
Comments