18 views 0 likes

Dr. CCHMC Pediatric Surgery

GCMD Space · View profile →

Update on Surgical Practice and Current State on Fontan Conversion Surgery:...

Video Published 2019-01-11 Updated 2022-08-22

Timestops (6)

Topic Overview

This discussion covers surgical interventions for failing Fontan circulation, including Fontan takedown, Fontan conversion, heart transplantation, and lymphatic decompression. The speakers review outcomes data showing that early Fontan takedown (typically within 0.6-2 months post-Fontan) has 20-25% early mortality but can salvage some patients for future Fontan or transplant. Fontan conversion—primarily for atrial-pulmonary Fontans with arrhythmias—achieves best arrhythmia control with bi-atrial maze procedures, though the procedure's relevance is declining as atrial-pulmonary Fontans become rare. Heart transplantation in Fontan patients requires careful management of thin-walled, low-pressure pulmonary arteries, often using circulatory arrest for reconstruction. Lymphatic decompression via innominate vein rerouting shows early promise for protein-losing enteropathy but remains experimental.

Key Takeaways

  • Early Fontan takedown has 20-25% mortality but can salvage patients for future Fontan or transplant within median 0.6-2 months post-op. (4:33)
  • Bi-atrial maze during Fontan conversion achieves best arrhythmia control; more complete lesion sets reduce recurrence risk. (6:55)
  • Fontan pulmonary arteries are thin-walled and low-pressure; use circulatory arrest for reconstruction during transplant to avoid injury. (14:48)
  • Prophylactic Fontan conversion in arrhythmia-free patients may prevent late deaths and protein-losing enteropathy per Japanese data. (10:45)
  • ECMO unlikely to fix elevated end-diastolic pressure or high PVR in early Fontan failure and may worsen these conditions. (20:56)

Inside this episode

Kai, the Library's AI content creator, listened to this episode and mapped who's speaking, the chapters, key claims, and cases. Every item links to the exact moment in the recording.

AI-enriched

Who's speaking

  • Speaker 1 — host
  • Doctor Veltman — host
  • Doctor Twaddle — guest

Chapters

  • 0:00Introduction and Overview of Post-Fontan Surgical Options — Introduction of Dr. Twaddle and overview of surgical procedures after completion Fontan: takedown, conversion, transplant, and lymphatic decompression.
  • 2:45Fontan Takedown: Indications and Outcomes — Discussion of Fontan takedown for early failure, reviewing multi-institutional data showing 20-25% early mortality, with some patients salvaged for future Fontan or transplant. Late takedown outcomes are generally poor.
  • 6:30Fontan Conversion: Technique and Results — Detailed review of Fontan conversion for atrial-pulmonary Fontans with arrhythmias, including maze lesion sets, arrhythmia recurrence rates, and patient selection criteria. Discussion of declining relevance as atrial-pulmonary Fontans become rare.
  • 13:46Heart Transplantation: Technical Considerations — Surgical approach to heart transplantation in Fontan patients, focusing on management of thin-walled pulmonary arteries, use of circulatory arrest, and reconstruction techniques.
  • 16:48Lymphatic Decompression and Future Directions — Introduction of thoracic duct decompression via innominate vein rerouting for protein-losing enteropathy, with discussion of early results and future role of mechanical support and transplantation.
  • 19:32Interactive Case Discussion and Q&A — Review of audience poll questions covering early Fontan failure management, arrhythmia procedures, and contraindications to Fontan conversion. Discussion of late Fontan takedown feasibility in adults.

Key claims

  • 1:41The Fontan is a surgically created condition of severe chronic right heart failure with sequelae including venous hypertension, hepatic congestion, lymphatic congestion, restrictive lung disease, altered pulmonary vasculature, and single ventricle dysfunction — Doctor Twaddle
  • 2:45Fontan takedown is generally done early, with indications being low cardiac output and elevated CVP, frequently resulting in a progressive downward spiral — Doctor Twaddle
  • 4:03Bambino Gesù in Rome reported 18 Fontan takedowns over 25 years (1990-2015), with 2 in immediate postoperative period and 16 within 2 months of completion Fontan — Doctor Twaddle
  • 4:33In the Bambino Gesù series, 17 were early survivors, 3 underwent subsequent successful Fontan palliation, 4 underwent transplantation with 2 late survivors, and 10 remained with bidirectional Glenn physiology at median 7-year follow-up — Doctor Twaddle
  • 5:10European multi-institutional registry study (1971-2012) reported 38 Fontan takedowns with average time from Fontan to takedown of 0.6 years — Doctor Twaddle
  • 5:43In the European registry, early mortality was approximately 25%, with 5 late deaths, 4 underwent heart transplantation with 2 deaths, 2 underwent subsequent Fontan, and 44% reached final endpoint by study conclusion — Doctor Twaddle
  • 6:30Fontan conversion is primarily used for patients after atrial pulmonary Fontan with atrial arrhythmias — Doctor Twaddle
  • 6:55Fontan conversion always involves large reduction of the atrium combined with maze operation or lesion set to prevent propagation of macro-reentrant circuits, which are the mechanism for most arrhythmias encountered — Doctor Twaddle
  • 9:15The more complete the arrhythmia procedure (bi-atrial maze vs right atrial maze vs isthmal ablation), the lower the risk of arrhythmia recurrence — Doctor Twaddle
  • 9:53Chicago group reported Fontan conversion mortality of 1.4%, while multi-center trials showed early mortality around 10% — Doctor Twaddle
  • 10:19Conditional survival after Fontan conversion appears similar between European experience and Chicago, suggesting mortality difference is primarily due to patient selection and execution of operation — Doctor Twaddle
  • 10:45Japanese study of 32 patients found that 7 patients who underwent prophylactic Fontan conversion without arrhythmias had no late deaths and were completely free from arrhythmias and protein-losing enteropathy — Doctor Twaddle
  • 12:07Candidates for Fontan conversion require preserved ventricular function and preserved end organ function — Doctor Twaddle
  • 12:15Contraindications to Fontan conversion include protein-losing enteropathy, older age (related to elevation of end-diastolic pressure), ascites, right or indeterminate ventricular morphology, and bi-atrial arrhythmia operation — Doctor Twaddle
  • 13:04In Australia and New Zealand, the only type of Fontan performed since 2007 is extra-cardiac conduit, with atrial-pulmonary Fontans peaking in early 1990s and now decreasing — Doctor Twaddle
  • 14:13All Fontan patients being considered for transplant will have concerning pulmonary artery anatomy — Doctor Twaddle
  • 14:48Pulmonary arteries in Fontan patients have been at low pressure throughout life, can be very delicate and thin-walled, with many aorto-pulmonary collaterals creating surgical challenges — Doctor Twaddle
  • 15:44Hilar pulmonary arteries in Fontan patients are very thin, frequently manipulated at previous surgery, may be deserosalized with adventitia removed, and are very prone to injury that can be challenging to repair — Doctor Twaddle
  • 16:00Preferred strategy for pulmonary artery reconstruction during Fontan transplant is to perform this part of operation with circulatory arrest, manipulating only central pulmonary arteries — Doctor Twaddle
  • 16:59Lymphatic circulation drains into central venous circulation, so venous hypertension results in lymphatic hypertension, leading to protein-losing enteropathy and plastic bronchitis — Doctor Twaddle
  • 17:17Most lymphatic drainage from lower half of body and left half of trunk drains to junction of left internal jugular vein and innominate vein — Doctor Twaddle
  • 17:55Doctor Hiroska published two case reports of innominate vein detachment from SVC and anastomosis to low-pressure atrium, with improvement in protein-losing enteropathy — Doctor Twaddle
  • 18:04Christian Creutzer suggested creating second detachment of proximal innominate vein from left internal jugular and subclavian vein, then restructuring innominate vein using Gore-Tex tube graft to avoid right-to-left shunting and cyanosis — Doctor Twaddle
  • 19:11The best hope for long-term survival probably rests with mechanical support and transplantation, requiring better understanding of support, sensitization, and immunosuppression — Doctor Twaddle
  • 20:56In early Fontan failure scenario with good ventricular function, no pathway obstruction, and sinus rhythm, patient likely has elevation of end-diastolic pressure or increased pulmonary vascular resistance as cause of failure — Doctor Twaddle
  • 21:16ECMO (VA or VV) is unlikely to fix elevated end-diastolic pressure or increased pulmonary vascular resistance and may make them worse — Doctor Twaddle
  • 24:36Older patients who have been acyanotic, even if cardiac output is improved, will not do well if subjected to significant cyanosis that would be well tolerated in a small child — Doctor Twaddle

Cases discussed

  • 19:42Eight-year-old male with heterotaxy syndrome, post-op day 2 from fenestrated Fontan, presenting with low output syndrome

Open questions

  • Whether prophylactic Fontan conversion is justified for asymptomatic patients with atrial-pulmonary Fontan, given uncertain natural history without intervention
  • Whether late Fontan takedown (beyond early postoperative period) is a realistic option for adults with failing Fontan who are not transplant candidates
  • Long-term outcomes and optimal patient selection for lymphatic decompression procedures
  • How to better understand and manage sensitization and immunosuppression in Fontan patients requiring transplantation
This episode was analyzed and enriched by Kai, the Library's AI content creator. Every item links to the moment it comes from — click a timestamp to listen in context.

Surgical Options When the Fontan Circulation Fails

The episode's main topic retold as a plain-language walkthrough — what it is, why it matters, and what the speakers concluded. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For the care team · Explainer · AI-written, human-reviewed

Why This Exists

The Fontan operation creates a circulation in which systemic venous blood flows passively to the lungs without a pumping chamber — a necessary solution for children born with only one functional ventricle. It is also, as one surgeon puts it, "a surgically created condition of severe chronic right heart failure" 1:41. Venous hypertension drives hepatic congestion, lymphatic overload, restrictive lung disease, and progressive ventricular dysfunction. When this physiology decompensates — whether weeks after completion or decades later — a small set of salvage operations exists. This discussion reviews the evidence and technical considerations for each.

The Core Problem

Fontan failure presents along a spectrum. Early failure, within weeks to months of the operation, typically reflects low cardiac output and elevated central venous pressure in a patient whose anatomy appeared adequate 2:45. Late failure, years out, more often involves arrhythmias (especially in older atrial-pulmonary connections), protein-losing enteropathy, or end-organ decline. The surgical response depends on timing, underlying physiology, and what remains salvageable.

Fontan Takedown: Early Salvage

Takedown — converting the completed Fontan back to a bidirectional Glenn — is almost always an early operation. In a 25-year series from Rome, 16 of 18 takedowns occurred within two months of the initial Fontan 4:03. A European registry reported similar timing, with average interval of 0.6 years 5:10. Early mortality is substantial: approximately 25% in the registry series 5:43, though the Rome group reported 17 of 18 early survivors 4:33.

What happens to survivors? In the Rome series, three eventually underwent successful re-Fontan, four were transplanted (two survived long-term), and ten remained with Glenn physiology at median seven-year follow-up 4:33. The registry showed similar patterns: some bridged to transplant, some to re-Fontan, many remained with Glenn 5:43. This is salvage for a desperate cohort, but it does salvage some.

Late takedown — attempting this in an adult years after Fontan — is rarely reported and outcomes are generally poor 2:45. The physiology that an infant tolerates (chronic cyanosis at Glenn-level saturations) becomes poorly tolerated in an older patient who has been acyanotic for years. As one discussant notes, improving cardiac output may subject patients to significant cyanosis that, though well tolerated in small children, is poorly tolerated in older patients 24:36.

Fontan Conversion: An Arrhythmia Operation

Conversion — replacing an atrial-pulmonary Fontan with an extracardiac conduit, reducing the massively dilated atrium, and performing a maze procedure — is primarily an arrhythmia operation 6:30. The enlarged atrium creates substrate for macro-reentrant circuits; the conversion eliminates that substrate 6:55.

The completeness of the arrhythmia procedure matters. Bi-atrial maze produces lower recurrence rates than right atrial maze alone, which in turn outperforms simple isthmal ablation 9:15. Lesions are created by incision and cryoablation, adapted to each patient's anatomy.

Mortality varies by center and patient selection. The Chicago group, the largest single-center experience, reports 1.4% early mortality; multicenter data shows closer to 10% 9:53. Conditional survival after the early period appears similar across series, suggesting the difference reflects patient selection and operative execution rather than the procedure itself 10:19.

Candidates require preserved ventricular function and preserved end-organ function 12:07. Contraindications include protein-losing enteropathy, older age (likely reflecting elevated end-diastolic pressure), ascites, right or indeterminate ventricular morphology, and need for bi-atrial arrhythmia surgery 12:15. A Japanese series raised the question of prophylactic conversion in well patients with atrial-pulmonary Fontans: seven such patients had no late deaths and remained free of arrhythmias and protein-losing enteropathy 10:45. Whether this justifies the approach remains unclear.

The relevance of Fontan conversion is declining. In Australia and New Zealand, only extracardiac conduits have been performed since 2007; the population with atrial-pulmonary Fontans peaked in the early 1990s and is now decreasing 13:04. The number of patients with atrial-pulmonary Fontans requiring conversion may represent a time-limited concern 13:04.

Transplantation: The Pulmonary Artery Problem

All Fontan patients being considered for transplant will have concerning pulmonary artery anatomy 14:13. These vessels have been at low pressure throughout life, are thin-walled and delicate, and are surrounded by aortopulmonary collaterals 14:48. The hilar branches are particularly treacherous — frequently manipulated at prior surgeries, sometimes with adventitia stripped away, prone to injury that is extremely difficult to repair from behind 15:44.

The preferred approach is to perform pulmonary artery reconstruction during brief circulatory arrest, manipulating only the central vessels and avoiding the fragile hilar branches entirely 16:00. "If you get an injury in the back of one of these vessels, it can be really very challenging to repair" [q4].

Lymphatic Decompression: Early Experience

Venous hypertension produces lymphatic hypertension, which drives protein-losing enteropathy and plastic bronchitis 16:59. Most lymphatic drainage from the lower body and left trunk enters the venous system at the junction of the left internal jugular and innominate veins 17:17. Detaching the innominate vein from the superior vena cava and anastomosing it to the low-pressure atrium decompresses the lymphatic system; two case reports showed improvement in protein-losing enteropathy 17:55. A modification adds a Gore-Tex interposition graft to prevent right-to-left shunting and cyanosis 18:04. Experience remains very early.

When to Involve This Team

Early Fontan failure with low output and elevated CVP, especially without an obvious anatomic problem to revise, warrants discussion of takedown. ECMO is unlikely to reverse elevated end-diastolic pressure or increased pulmonary vascular resistance and may worsen both 21:16. Late Fontan patients with refractory atrial arrhythmias and preserved function may be conversion candidates if they have an atrial-pulmonary connection. Protein-losing enteropathy in any Fontan patient should prompt evaluation for lymphatic decompression or transplant. Long-term survival likely depends on advances in mechanical support and transplantation, including better understanding of support strategies, sensitization, and immunosuppression 19:11.

Takeaways from this story

  • Early Fontan takedown carries 25% mortality but can bridge some patients to re-Fontan or transplant; late takedown is rarely successful.
  • Fontan conversion is an arrhythmia operation requiring preserved function; bi-atrial maze reduces recurrence more than limited lesion sets.
  • Pulmonary arteries in Fontan patients are thin-walled and injury-prone; reconstruction during circulatory arrest avoids hilar vessel trauma.
  • Rerouting the innominate vein to low-pressure atrium may decompress lymphatics and improve protein-losing enteropathy.

Keywords

Hashtags

Transcript

Comments

Loading comments…