13 views 0 likes

Dr. CCHMC Pediatric Surgery

GCMD Space · View profile →

Hirschsprung Disease: Radiology Aspect

Video Published 2019-01-11 Updated 2026-06-10

Timestops (6)

Topic Overview

A multidisciplinary discussion on the radiologic diagnosis of Hirschsprung disease, emphasizing contrast enema technique and interpretation challenges. The speakers address the 20-25% false-negative rate of contrast enemas, the poor concordance (62%) between radiologic and pathologic transition zones in long-segment disease, and the importance of proper technique—including avoiding Foley catheters in the rectum and using slow contrast infusion under fluoroscopy. The discussion includes recognition of post-operative anatomy (Soave, Duhamel procedures) and a debate on ultra-short segment disease versus idiopathic constipation, with one speaker challenging the anatomic basis of internal anal sphincter achalasia.

Key Takeaways

  • Contrast enema has 20-25% false-negative rate; 25% concordance with pathology in long-segment disease makes repeat studies futile. (9:47)
  • Never use Foley catheter in rectum—misses short-segment disease. Use slow gravity infusion with 50% diluted contrast under fluoroscopy. (15:57)
  • Enterocolitis in newborn is Hirschsprung until proven otherwise. Biopsy nearly all patients needing contrast enema for obstruction. (7:29)
  • Duhamel pouch obstruction suggests patient may never have had true Hirschsprung—aganglionic rectum does not dilate even after years. (35:06)
  • Ultra-short segment Hirschsprung cannot be differentiated from idiopathic constipation; internal sphincter achalasia is manometric, not anatomic. (40:15)

Inside this episode

Kai, the Library's AI content creator, listened to this episode and mapped who's speaking, the chapters, key claims, and cases. Every item links to the exact moment in the recording.

AI-enriched

Who's speaking

  • Speaker 1 — guest
  • Speaker 2 — host
  • Andrea — host
  • Rodrigo Ocelami — guest
  • Dr. Pena — guest
  • Dr. Collins — guest

Chapters

  • 0:00Plain Radiograph Findings in Hirschsprung Disease — Introduction to radiologic signs of Hirschsprung disease on plain abdominal radiographs, including distal bowel obstruction, dilated loops, and enterocolitis. Emphasis on fluoroscopy as a declining art and the importance of proper technique.
  • 4:56Accuracy and Limitations of Contrast Enema — Discussion of the 20-25% false-negative rate and 43% false-positive transition zone rate of contrast enemas. Review of a study showing 90% radiologist agreement on transition zones but only 62% concordance with pathology, particularly poor (25%) in long-segment disease.
  • 10:36Contrast Enema Technique — Dr. Ocelami presents technique: insert rectal tube 2-3 cm (never use Foley catheter), use 50% diluted water-soluble contrast, inject slowly via syringe under continuous fluoroscopy, obtain lateral and AP images, and counsel families about post-procedure hydration and contrast appearance.
  • 20:46Case Examples and Transition Zone Interpretation — Presentation of multiple cases demonstrating short-segment, long-segment, and total colonic Hirschsprung disease. Includes a case initially appearing as small left colon syndrome that proved to be total colonic aganglionosis with terminal ileum transition, illustrating the unreliability of radiologic transition zones in proximal disease.
  • 30:59Post-operative Anatomy Recognition — Review of contrast enema appearances after Soave (widened presacral space from muscular cuff) and Duhamel (anterior pouch) procedures. Discussion of using lateral views to assess presacral space and identify retained aganglionic tissue.
  • 34:26Ultra-short Segment Disease and Internal Sphincter Achalasia Debate — Case of dilated colon with normal-appearing rectum prompts discussion of differential diagnosis. Dr. Pena challenges the concepts of ultra-short segment Hirschsprung disease and internal anal sphincter achalasia, arguing there is no anatomic basis for a distinct internal sphincter and that the normal physiologic aganglionic segment length at different ages has never been accurately determined.

Key claims

  • 0:20Fluoroscopy was done very well in the 1960s and 1970s when it was the primary modality, but with the advent of MRI, CT, and ultrasound, fluoroscopy has become almost a lost art — Speaker 1
  • 0:56Signs of Hirschsprung disease on plain abdominal radiographs include distal bowel obstruction, dilated colon, and bowel mucosal irregularities — Speaker 1
  • 2:38In a newborn, you cannot tell the difference between colon and small bowel on plain radiographs — Speaker 1
  • 2:52Bubbles of meconium in the bowel are not necessarily pneumatosis and are a fairly common appearance — Speaker 1
  • 3:12The most common causes of distal bowel obstruction in neonates are Hirschsprung disease, small left colon syndrome (meconium plug syndrome), anorectal malformation, meconium ileus, and ileal atresia, which make up about 99% of cases — Speaker 1
  • 7:29Enterocolitis in a newborn should be considered Hirschsprung disease until proven otherwise — Speaker 1
  • 9:47The false negative rate of contrast enema for Hirschsprung disease is between 20% and 25% — Speaker 1
  • 10:35The false positive transition zone rate on contrast enema is up to 43% — Speaker 1
  • 10:50Radiologist agreement on the location of the transition zone is fairly high at 90% — Speaker 1
  • 11:02The concordance rate between radiology and pathology for transition zone location is only about 62% — Speaker 1
  • 12:43For short segment (rectosigmoid) disease, the concordance between radiologic and pathologic transition zones is about 75% — Speaker 1
  • 13:09For long segment disease (descending colon, splenic flexure, or more proximal), the concordance between radiologic and pathologic transition zones is only about 25% — Speaker 1
  • 13:44Repeat enemas in patients with long segment disease are futile and will not give better knowledge of the transition zone location — Speaker 1
  • 15:57Never use a Foley catheter inside the rectum for contrast enema — Rodrigo Ocelami
  • 16:19Use water-soluble contrast diluted 50% with saline for neonatal contrast enemas — Rodrigo Ocelami
  • 16:31Inject contrast very slowly and gently via syringe under continuous fluoroscopy to avoid distending the aganglionic segment — Rodrigo Ocelami
  • 16:56After the neonatal period, only fill the colon up to the transverse colon if the distal segments appear normal — Rodrigo Ocelami
  • 17:25Take images in left lateral, right lateral decubitus, and AP positions, and remove the tube to visualize the rectum without obstruction — Rodrigo Ocelami
  • 19:23Always counsel families about post-procedure hydration and show them the contrast material so they know what to expect when the child evacuates — Rodrigo Ocelami
  • 20:59The iodinated water-soluble contrast used has an osmolality of about 400, similar to colon-cleansing agents, which helps clean the colon but can cause dehydration in neonates if it remains — Speaker 1
  • 21:45Use gravity infusion rather than injection, with large-bore IV tubing from a bag, at a moderate pace to rapidly visualize both distal and proximal segments — Speaker 1
  • 22:18Early maximal distention is best for seeing the transition zone because waiting too long can cause distention of the distal aganglionic segment — Speaker 1
  • 23:53If a Foley catheter balloon is inflated in the distal rectum, it will miss very short segment Hirschsprung disease every time — Speaker 1
  • 25:02Contrast enemas in premature infants do not follow the rules and may show a small colon that could be immaturity rather than Hirschsprung disease — Speaker 1
  • 25:18Contrast enemas can be performed in premature infants as young as 35-36 weeks gestational age with reasonable diagnostic accuracy — Speaker 1
  • 25:30Below 35-36 weeks, when necrotizing enterocolitis becomes more prevalent, diagnostic accuracy of contrast enema decreases — Speaker 1
  • 26:45The rectosigmoid transition in Hirschsprung disease is typically at the S2 level; if distal to S1-S2 it is considered distal rectal disease — Speaker 1
  • 27:21Small left colon syndrome typically has a transition at the splenic flexure that is very abrupt — Speaker 1
  • 28:48The rectosigmoid index (rectum larger than sigmoid) is a good principle but not definitive; the entire colon up to the splenic flexure should be evaluated — Speaker 1
  • 30:14In patients with proximal transition zones, the actual pathologic transition can be much more proximal than the radiologic appearance suggests — Speaker 1
  • 30:34For patients with high transition zones on enema, a more invasive approach (laparoscopic or open) may be preferable to transanal pull-through because the true transition location is uncertain — Speaker 1
  • 31:01Rectal biopsy should be performed in almost any patient who needed a contrast enema to rule out distal obstruction, including cases of meconium plug or small left colon — Speaker 2
  • 31:35In clearly diagnosed meconium ileus with reflux into terminal ileum and clinical improvement, rectal biopsy may not be necessary — Speaker 2
  • 33:42In the Soave procedure, partial thickness dissection leaves a muscular cuff that causes widening of the presacral space visible on lateral radiographs — Speaker 1
  • 35:06The Duhamel procedure creates a chimera of aganglionic distal segment with ganglionic proximal segment, forming an anterior pouch that can fill with stool and cause obstruction — Speaker 1
  • 36:09Patients with untreated Hirschsprung disease never develop a dilated rectum, even after 10-15 years, because by definition the aganglionic segment does not distend — Dr. Pena
  • 36:45Patients who develop the characteristic dilated Duhamel pouch may never have had true Hirschsprung disease, and pathologists should carefully examine resected pouches for ganglion cells — Dr. Pena
  • 39:43In a patient with a contrast enema showing dilated colon with normal-appearing rectum and presacral space, rectal biopsy is a waste of time because the patient does not have Hirschsprung disease — Dr. Pena
  • 40:15There is no way to differentiate so-called ultra-short segment Hirschsprung disease from idiopathic constipation — Dr. Pena
  • 40:47The length of the normal physiologic aganglionic segment in the distal rectum has never been accurately determined at different ages in humans — Dr. Pena
  • 41:29The internal anal sphincter is defined as a thickening of the circular muscle layer, but this thickening has never been consistently demonstrated anatomically and its exact limits at different ages have never been determined — Dr. Pena
  • 42:31Internal anal sphincter achalasia is a manometric concept, not an anatomic concept — Dr. Pena
  • 42:48Botulinum toxin injection paralyzes muscle and facilitates stool passage but does not cure a condition of unknown origin — Dr. Pena

Cases discussed

  • 27:04Two-day-old male with failure to pass meconium, contrast enema showed abrupt transition at splenic flexure initially interpreted as small left colon syndrome
  • 7:23Patient with total intestinal Hirschsprung disease presenting with enterocolitis

Points of disagreement

  • 31:01Necessity of rectal biopsy in small left colon syndrome
    • Speaker 2: Always perform rectal biopsy in any patient requiring contrast enema for distal obstruction, including small left colon and meconium plug cases
    • Dr. Pena: In a patient with contrast enema showing dilated colon with normal rectum, rectal biopsy is a waste of time because the patient does not have Hirschsprung disease
  • 39:43Validity of ultra-short segment Hirschsprung disease and internal sphincter achalasia as distinct entities
    • Dr. Pena: Ultra-short segment Hirschsprung disease cannot be differentiated from idiopathic constipation; internal sphincter achalasia is a manometric concept without anatomic basis; myectomies and botulinum toxin injections are not treating a defined anatomic condition
  • 36:01Pathology of dilated Duhamel pouch
    • Dr. Pena: Patients who develop dilated Duhamel pouches may never have had true Hirschsprung disease because aganglionic rectum should not distend; pathologists should examine resected pouches for ganglion cells
    • Dr. Collins: Resected Duhamel pouches examined have contained both ganglionic and aganglionic parts

Open questions

  • What is the exact length of the normal physiologic aganglionic segment in the distal rectum at different ages in humans?
  • Does the internal anal sphincter exist as a distinct anatomic structure with measurable thickening of the circular muscle layer?
  • Do patients who develop dilated Duhamel pouches actually have ganglion cells in the retained rectal segment, suggesting they never had true Hirschsprung disease?
  • Can ultra-short segment Hirschsprung disease be reliably differentiated from idiopathic constipation?
  • What is the optimal surgical approach for patients with high transition zones on contrast enema given the poor concordance with pathology?
This episode was analyzed and enriched by Kai, the Library's AI content creator. Every item links to the moment it comes from — click a timestamp to listen in context.
Written for:

Keywords

Hashtags

Transcript

Comments

Loading comments…