26 views 0 likes

Dr. CCHMC Pediatric Surgery

GCMD Space · View profile →

Case Review Dynamic Assessment of the Fontan Part II: New Horizons in Medical...

Video Published 2019-01-11 Updated 2022-08-22

Timestops (4)

Topic Overview

A presentation on non-invasive dynamic assessment of Fontan circulation, focusing on peripheral venous pressure monitoring during exercise to detect occult physiologic abnormalities. The speaker demonstrates a case of a 45-year-old Fontan patient with declining functional capacity and elevated liver stiffness, in whom exercise testing revealed dramatic venous pressure elevation to 40 mmHg and abnormal venous compliance. The discussion addresses the tension between encouraging exercise participation for improved capacity versus the risk of exercise-induced central venous hypertension and end-organ damage, with limited data on whether exercise training modifies hemodynamic responses or whether different exercise modalities produce different physiologic effects.

Key Takeaways

  • Peripheral venous pressure monitoring during exercise detects occult Fontan abnormalities missed by echo and clinical assessment alone. (7:31)
  • Fontan patients show precipitous renal NIRS drops during exercise that persist 5-6 minutes into recovery, unlike cerebral NIRS. (5:02)
  • Hepatic venous pressures >25 mmHg cause subclinical hepatocellular damage; reduced venous compliance accelerates pressure rise with exercise. (4:11)
  • Exercise improves Fontan capacity via skeletal muscle adaptation, but central venous hypertension may cause end-organ damage at extremes. (8:16)
  • Submaximal exercise protocols capture most venous pressure rise; no data shows exercise modality or training alters hemodynamic response. (10:06)

Inside this episode

Kai, the Library's AI content creator, listened to this episode and mapped who's speaking, the chapters, key claims, and cases. Every item links to the exact moment in the recording.

AI-enriched

Who's speaking

  • Speaker 1 — guest
  • Speaker 2
  • Speaker 3
  • Speaker 4

Chapters

  • 0:00Introduction and Case Presentation — Introduction to non-invasive assessment of Fontan circulation before catheterization. Presentation of a 45-year-old patient with transposition and tricuspid atresia, prior Fontan revision, declining functional capacity, and elevated liver stiffness despite no circuit obstruction on MRI.
  • 2:15Exercise Testing Methodology — Description of peripheral venous pressure monitoring technique using antecubital cannula during exercise, including measurement of mean capillary filling pressure and near-infrared spectroscopy. Validation data showing correlation between peripheral and central venous pressures.
  • 4:21Case Results and Catheterization Findings — Patient's exercise test showed venous pressure rising from 17-18 to 40 mmHg, liver stiffness increasing from 3.5 to 4.0 m/s, and response to inhaled treprostinil. Catheterization confirmed elevated Fontan pressures (17 at rest, 25 with volume challenge), elevated wedge pressures, and abnormal venous compliance and diastolic function.
  • 7:31Discussion: Exercise Benefits vs Risks — Discussion of the paradox between exercise benefits for Fontan patients and exercise-induced central venous hypertension causing end-organ damage. Questions raised about optimal exercise intensity, whether training modifies hemodynamic responses, differences between exercise modalities, and whether supine exercise offers advantages (data suggests it does not).

Key claims

  • 1:41In normal individuals, acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) liver stiffness measures approximately 0.5 to 1 meter per second — Speaker 1
  • 3:18Peripheral venous pressure is highly correlated with central venous pressure in Fontan patients — Speaker 1
  • 3:26Mean capillary filling pressure measured peripherally is highly correlated with values obtained in the catheterization laboratory — Speaker 1
  • 3:41Mean capillary filling pressure is measured by applying an arm cuff to completely occlude arterial inflow and waiting for venous pressures in the arm to equalize — Speaker 1
  • 3:57Mean capillary filling pressure is a measure of intravascular volume status and venous wall tension and compliance — Speaker 1
  • 4:11In Fontan circulation patients, venous compliance is very often reduced — Speaker 1
  • 4:40Fontan patients who respond rapidly with venous pressure elevation during exercise tend to have diminished exercise capacity — Speaker 1
  • 5:02Fontan patients drop their renal near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) very precipitously and very early during exercise compared to normal controls — Speaker 1
  • 5:15In Fontan patients, renal NIRS does not return to normal even after 5-6 minutes of recovery following exercise — Speaker 1
  • 5:24Cerebral NIRS shows an early drop in Fontan patients but returns back to normal by the second minute of exercise, in contrast to renal NIRS — Speaker 1
  • 5:57When venous pressures transduced to the hepatic veins exceed 25 millimeters of mercury for any length of time, subclinical evidence of hepatocellular damage occurs due to perfusion problems — Speaker 1
  • 7:31Dynamic assessment of the Fontan patient is essential even in well-functioning Fontans to pick up occult abnormal physiology that would not be appreciated until much later when the patient becomes ill — Speaker 1
  • 8:16Exercise participation, whether formal or informal, improves exercise capacity in Fontan patients — Speaker 2
  • 8:38With exercise comes central venous hypertension which causes liver disease among other things in Fontan patients — Speaker 2
  • 9:04With any form of exercise, if you take the extremes, the detrimental effects may well outweigh the beneficial effects — Speaker 1
  • 10:06Most of the venous pressure rise during exercise is already incorporated into submaximal exercise protocols — Speaker 2
  • 10:36Patients on a transplant list get better if you exercise them, largely because of skeletal muscle function and oxygen extraction improvements — Speaker 3
  • 10:51The hemodynamic response to exercise may or may not change with exercise training — Speaker 3
  • 11:15In Fontan patients, vessels themselves change in their histopathology to accommodate higher pressures, with perivenular changes in the liver and vascular adaptive responses in the SVC and IVC — Speaker 1
  • 11:38There is virtually no data in any condition suggesting that if you change vascular biology acutely, you change exercise function — Speaker 3
  • 13:15In biventricular patients, supine exercise is limited compared to upright exercise — Speaker 2
  • 13:38In Fontan patients, exercise limitation during supine exercise looks the same as in biventricular patients, with no particular advantage to swimming or other flat exercises — Speaker 2
  • 13:48Gravity affects flow patterns in Fontan patients, with very different patterns of hepatic venous flow depending on whether lying flat or standing up — Speaker 3
  • 14:10Exercise testing with venous pressure monitoring can detect occult obstructions in the Fontan circuit that may not be identified with echo and clinical assessment alone — Speaker 1

Cases discussed

  • 0:2145-year-old male with transposition and tricuspid atresia, prior Fontan revision for atrial tachycardia, presenting with declining functional capacity

Points of disagreement

  • 10:22Whether exercise training modifies hemodynamic responses in Fontan patients
    • Speaker 1: Suspects by clinical experience that patients' hemodynamic response to exercise shifts after training
    • Speaker 3: Questions whether hemodynamics change with training, noting that exercise benefits in transplant patients come from skeletal muscle and oxygen extraction improvements, not necessarily hemodynamic changes

Open questions

  • What is the optimal exercise intensity for Fontan patients that maximizes benefits while minimizing venous hypertension and end-organ damage?
  • Does exercise training modify the hemodynamic response to exercise in Fontan patients, or do improvements come solely from peripheral adaptations?
  • Do different exercise modalities (cardiovascular vs. isometric vs. supine) produce different hemodynamic responses in Fontan patients?
  • Can peripheral venous pressure monitoring during exercise be used to guide individualized exercise prescriptions for Fontan patients?
  • Does vascular remodeling in response to chronic venous hypertension provide any functional benefit, or is it purely a structural adaptation?
This episode was analyzed and enriched by Kai, the Library's AI content creator. Every item links to the moment it comes from — click a timestamp to listen in context.
Written for:

Occult Venous Hypertension in a Declining Fontan: When Exercise Testing Reveals Hidden Physiology

The patient case from this episode, retold from presentation to outcome with the decisions made along the way. Written by Kai from the episode transcript and reviewed before publishing.

For the care team · Case narrative · AI-written, human-reviewed

Presentation

A 45-year-old man with transposition and tricuspid atresia presented with declining functional capacity 1:41. He had undergone Fontan revision years earlier for uncontrolled atrial tachycardia and had been relatively stable until recently. Peak VO₂ was significantly diminished. MRI showed no obstruction in the Fontan circuit and good-sized pulmonary arteries, yet acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) liver stiffness measured 3.5 meters per second — markedly elevated compared to the normal range of 0.5 to 1 meter per second 1:41. The imaging was reassuring, but the patient was not.

The Decision Point

The clinical question was straightforward: why was this patient declining when structural imaging showed no obvious problem? One discussant acknowledged the dilemma directly: the choice between sending every declining Fontan patient to the catheterization laboratory versus using noninvasive screening first 3:18 3:26. The alternative was exercise testing with peripheral venous pressure monitoring via an antecubital cannula 3:18 3:26.

The rationale rested on validated correlations: peripheral venous pressure tracks central venous pressure closely in Fontan patients 3:18, and mean capillary filling pressure measured peripherally — by occluding arterial inflow with an arm cuff and allowing venous pressures to equalize — correlates well with catheterization laboratory values 3:26 3:41. This measurement reflects both intravascular volume status and venous wall tension and compliance 3:57, the latter often reduced in Fontan circulation 4:11.

What the Team Did

The patient underwent exercise testing with continuous peripheral venous pressure monitoring and near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS) of renal and cerebral beds. Baseline venous pressure was 17–18 mmHg. During exercise, it rose rapidly to 35 mmHg, then 40 mmHg [case1]. Liver stiffness increased from 3.5 to 4.0 meters per second during exercise [case1]. Renal NIRS dropped precipitously early in exercise and remained depressed even after five to six minutes of recovery 5:02 5:15, while cerebral NIRS showed an early drop but normalized by the second minute 5:24.

The team tested inhaled treprostinil during exercise, which improved the stiffness response [case1]. The patient then proceeded to catheterization. Resting Fontan pressures were 17 mmHg with wedge pressures elevated to 12 mmHg, yielding a transpulmonary gradient of 7 mmHg [case1]. With fluid volume challenge, Fontan pressures rose to 25 mmHg and wedge pressures to 18 mmHg, demonstrating abnormal venous compliance and diastolic dysfunction [case1].

What Happened

The outcome was not discussed beyond the catheterization findings. The case was presented to illustrate a diagnostic approach rather than a therapeutic result.

What the Case Changes

This case demonstrates that structural imaging alone is insufficient to explain functional decline in Fontan patients. Venous pressures exceeding 25 mmHg for any sustained period cause subclinical hepatocellular damage due to perfusion problems 5:57. Patients who respond rapidly with venous pressure elevation during exercise tend to have diminished exercise capacity 4:40, and this patient's rise to 40 mmHg was extreme.

The discussants emphasized that dynamic assessment is essential even in well-functioning Fontans to detect occult abnormal physiology that would not be appreciated until much later when the patient becomes ill 7:31. Exercise testing with venous pressure monitoring can identify obstructions in the Fontan circuit that may not be detected with echocardiography and clinical assessment alone 14:10.

The case also raised an unresolved tension: exercise participation improves exercise capacity in Fontan patients 8:16, yet exercise induces central venous hypertension that contributes to liver disease 8:38. One discussant noted that extreme exercise may have detrimental effects that outweigh beneficial effects 9:04. Most of the venous pressure rise is already present during submaximal exercise 10:06, complicating the prescription of safe exercise intensity. Whether exercise training alters the hemodynamic response to exercise remains uncertain 10:51, though patients awaiting transplant improve with exercise primarily through skeletal muscle function and oxygen extraction gains 10:36, not necessarily through hemodynamic adaptation. As one discussant put it, acute changes in vascular biology do not translate to changes in exercise function 11:38.

The vessels themselves appear to adapt histologically to accommodate higher pressures — perivenular changes in the liver and vascular remodeling in the SVC and IVC 11:15 — but whether this adaptation is protective or merely delays inevitable injury is unknown.

Takeaways from this story

  • Peripheral venous pressure monitoring during exercise can reveal occult Fontan dysfunction missed by structural imaging alone.
  • Venous pressures exceeding 25 mmHg cause subclinical hepatocellular damage; this patient reached 40 mmHg during exercise.
  • Renal NIRS drops precipitously during exercise in Fontan patients and remains depressed during recovery, unlike cerebral NIRS.
  • Exercise improves capacity but induces venous hypertension; whether training alters hemodynamic response remains uncertain.

Keywords

Hashtags

Transcript

Comments

Loading comments…